Gonzalez-Prieto Cristian, Wilson Daniel, Dobbie Gillian, Rivera-Rodriguez Claudia, Yates Susan, Rai-Bala Reshmi, Sani Tara, Dobson Rosie, Cullum Sarah
School of Computer Science, The University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Department of Statistics, The University of Auckland, New Zealand.
N Z Med J. 2023 Sep 15;136(1582):64-86. doi: 10.26635/6965.6181.
Routinely collected health data can provide rich information for research and epidemiological monitoring of different diseases, but using the data presents many challenges. This study aims to explore the attitudes and preferences of people aged 55 and over regarding the use of their de-identified health data, and their concerns and comfort in different scenarios.
An anonymous online survey was conducted with people aged 55 and over currently engaged with health services in a New Zealand health district during June-October 2022. The survey could be completed online or by telephone and was available in eight languages.
Seventy-nine percent of respondents knew that their health information was currently being used in the ways described in the scenarios, and between 80-87% felt comfortable or very comfortable with their data being used as described in the scenarios. In contrast, 4% (n=9) felt "uncomfortable" or "very uncomfortable" across all of the scenarios. Participants expressed concerns about data accuracy, privacy and confidentiality, security, transparency of use, consent, feedback and the risk of data being sold to commercial companies. Some participants identified situations where permission should be required to link data, including being used by people other than health professionals, containing sensitive health issues, or being used for commercial purposes.
This study finds general support from patients for the use of their routinely collected data for secondary purposes as long as its use will benefit the population from which the data are taken. It also highlights the necessity of including the perspectives of different cultures in the collection, storage, use and analysis of health information, particularly concerning Māori cultural considerations.
常规收集的健康数据可为不同疾病的研究和流行病学监测提供丰富信息,但使用这些数据存在诸多挑战。本研究旨在探讨55岁及以上人群对使用其去识别化健康数据的态度和偏好,以及他们在不同场景下的担忧和舒适度。
2022年6月至10月期间,对新西兰一个健康区目前正在接受医疗服务的55岁及以上人群进行了一项匿名在线调查。该调查可以在线或通过电话完成,有八种语言可供选择。
79%的受访者知道他们的健康信息目前正以场景中描述的方式被使用,80%-87%的受访者对其数据按场景中描述的方式被使用感到舒适或非常舒适。相比之下,4%(n=9)的受访者在所有场景中都感到“不舒服”或“非常不舒服”。参与者对数据准确性、隐私和保密性、安全性、使用透明度、同意、反馈以及数据被出售给商业公司的风险表示担忧。一些参与者指出,在将数据进行关联时应获得许可的情况,包括被医疗专业人员以外的人使用、包含敏感健康问题或被用于商业目的。
本研究发现,只要数据的使用将使数据来源人群受益,患者普遍支持将其常规收集的数据用于次要目的。它还强调了在健康信息的收集、存储、使用和分析中纳入不同文化观点的必要性,特别是涉及毛利文化方面的考虑。