Blessing R, Mann W, Beck C
HNO. 1986 Sep;34(9):372-5.
135 patients with BPPV and 56 patients with Meniere's disease were evaluated critically. The reliability of the diagnostic criteria (history and physical examination, audiograms and vestibular function tests) were compared. History, physical examination and patients' complaints were inconclusive. Moderate or severe medio- or pancochlear inner ear damage was more reliable, but not pathognomonic of Meniere's disease. Patients with BPPV had normal hearing or a high-frequency loss. Electronystagmographically recorded vestibular function tests were unreliable in establishing the diagnosis. The most valid test to distinguish BPPV and Meniere's disease was Hallpike's positional test, using Frenzel's spectacles for better observation of the provoked nystagmus.
对135例良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)患者和56例梅尼埃病患者进行了严格评估。比较了诊断标准(病史和体格检查、听力图和前庭功能测试)的可靠性。病史、体格检查和患者主诉无定论。中度或重度中内耳或全内耳损伤更具可靠性,但并非梅尼埃病的特征性表现。BPPV患者听力正常或有高频听力损失。眼震电图记录的前庭功能测试在确诊时不可靠。区分BPPV和梅尼埃病最有效的测试是Hallpike位置试验,使用Frenzel眼镜能更好地观察诱发的眼震。