Detsky A S, Abrams H B, McLaughlin J R, Drucker D J, Sasson Z, Johnston N, Scott J G, Forbath N, Hilliard J R
J Gen Intern Med. 1986 Jul-Aug;1(4):211-9. doi: 10.1007/BF02596184.
The authors prospectively studied 455 consecutive patients referred to the general medical consultation service for cardiac risk assessment prior to non-cardiac surgery, in order to validate a previously derived multifactorial index in their clinical setting. They also tested a version of the index that they had modified to reflect factors they believed to be important. For patients undergoing major surgery, the original index performed less well in the validation data set than in the original derivation set (p less than 0.05), but still added predictive information to a statistically significant degree (p less than 0.05). The modified index also added predictive information for patients undergoing both major and minor surgery, demonstrating an area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve of 0.75 (95% confidence interval of 0.70 to 0.80). A simple nomogram is presented which will enable conversion of pretest probabilities into posttest probabilities using the likelihood ratios associated with each risk score. It is recommended that clinicians estimate local overall complication rates (pretest probabilities) for the clinically relevant populations in their settings before they apply the predictive properties (likelihood ratios) demonstrated in this study in order to calculate cardiac risks for individual patients (posttest probabilities).
作者前瞻性地研究了455例连续转诊至普通内科会诊服务处,以便在非心脏手术前进行心脏风险评估的患者,目的是在其临床环境中验证先前得出的多因素指数。他们还测试了一个经过修改的指数版本,以反映他们认为重要的因素。对于接受大手术的患者,原始指数在验证数据集中的表现不如在原始推导集中(p<0.05),但仍在统计学上显著程度上增加了预测信息(p<0.05)。修改后的指数也为接受大手术和小手术的患者增加了预测信息,其受试者工作特征曲线下面积为0.75(95%置信区间为0.70至0.80)。本文给出了一个简单的列线图,可利用与每个风险评分相关的似然比将检验前概率转换为检验后概率。建议临床医生在应用本研究中显示的预测特性(似然比)以计算个体患者的心脏风险(检验后概率)之前,先估计其所在临床环境中临床相关人群的局部总体并发症发生率(检验前概率)。