University Institute for Primary Care (IuMFE), University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Center for Primary Care and Public Health, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
PLoS One. 2023 Sep 21;18(9):e0291837. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0291837. eCollection 2023.
Women are generally under-represented as authors of publications, and especially as last authors, but this under-representation may not be uniformly distributed across countries. We aimed to document by country and region the proportion of female authors (PFA) in high-impact general medical journals.
We used PyMed, a Python library that provides access to PubMed, to retrieve all PubMed articles published between January 2012 and December 2021 in the fifty general internal medicine journals with the highest 2020 impact factor according to Journal Citation Reports. We extracted first/last authors' main country of affiliation for all these articles using regular expressions and manual search, and grouped the countries into eight regions (North/Latin America, Western/Eastern Europe, Asia, Pacific, Middle East, and Africa). We used NamSor to determine first/last authors' gender and computed the PFA for each country/region.
We retrieved 163,537 publications for first authors and 135,392 for last authors. Gender could be determined for 160,891 and 133,373 publications, respectively. The PFA was 41% for first authors and 33% for last authors, but it varied widely by country (first authors: >50% for eight countries, maximum = 63% in Romania, minimum = 19% in Japan; last authors: >50% for two countries, maximum = 53% in Romania, minimum = 9% in Japan). The PFA also varied by region. It was highest for Eastern Europe (first authors = 53%, last authors = 40%), and lowest for Asia (36% and 29%) and the Middle East (35% and 27%).
We found that the PFA varied widely by country and region, and was lowest in Asia, particularly Japan, and the Middle East. The under-representation of women as authors of publications, especially in these two regions, needs to be addressed and correcting persistent gender discrimination in research should be a top priority.
女性在出版物作者中普遍代表性不足,尤其是作为最后作者,但这种代表性不足在各国之间的分布可能并不均匀。我们旨在按国家和地区记录高影响力综合医学期刊中女性作者的比例(PFA)。
我们使用 PyMed,这是一个提供对 PubMed 访问的 Python 库,检索了 2020 年期刊引文报告中影响因子最高的 50 种综合内科期刊在 2012 年 1 月至 2021 年 12 月期间发表的所有 PubMed 文章。我们使用正则表达式和手动搜索从所有这些文章中提取第一/最后作者主要归属国,并将这些国家分为八个地区(北美/拉丁美洲、西欧/东欧、亚洲、太平洋、中东和非洲)。我们使用 NamSor 来确定第一/最后作者的性别,并计算每个国家/地区的 PFA。
我们检索到了 163537 篇第一作者的出版物和 135392 篇最后作者的出版物。分别有 160891 篇和 133373 篇出版物可以确定性别。第一作者的 PFA 为 41%,最后作者的 PFA 为 33%,但因国家而异(第一作者:8 个国家超过 50%,最大值为罗马尼亚的 63%,最小值为日本的 19%;最后作者:两个国家超过 50%,最大值为罗马尼亚的 53%,最小值为日本的 9%)。PFA 也因地区而异。东欧最高(第一作者=53%,最后作者=40%),亚洲和中东最低(亚洲 36%和 29%,中东 35%和 27%)。
我们发现 PFA 因国家和地区而异,亚洲尤其是日本和中东地区最低。女性作为出版物作者的代表性不足,特别是在这两个地区,需要加以解决,纠正研究中持续存在的性别歧视应成为当务之急。