Department of Internal Medicine, Complexo Hospitalario Universitario de Santiago, Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital Universitario de Salamanca-IBSAL, University of Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain; Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital Virgen del Puerto, Plasencia, Cáceres, Spain.
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2023 Nov 1;252:110961. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2023.110961. Epub 2023 Sep 9.
Despite guidelines and recommendations, Wernicke's encephalopathy (WE) treatment lacks evidence, leading to clinical practice variability.
Given the overall lack of information on thiamine use for WE treatment, we analyzed data from a large, well-characterized multicenter sample of patients with WE, examining thiamine dosages; factors associated with the use of different doses, frequencies, and routes; and the influence of differences in thiamine treatment on the outcome.
This retrospective study was conducted with data from 443 patients from 21 centers obtained from a nationwide registry of the Spanish Society of Internal Medicine (from 2000 to 2012). Discharge codes and Caine criteria were applied for WE diagnosis, and treatment-related (thiamine dosage, frequency, and route of administration) demographic, clinical, and outcome variables were analyzed.
We found marked variability in WE treatment and a low rate of high-dose intravenous thiamine administration. Seventy-eight patients out of 373 (20.9%) received > 300mg/day of thiamine as initial dose. Patients fulfilling the Caine criteria or presenting with the classic WE triad more frequently received parenteral treatment. Delayed diagnosis (after 24h hospitalization), the fulfillment of more than two Caine criteria at diagnosis, mental status alterations, and folic acid deficiency were associated significantly with the lack of complete recovery. Malnutrition, reduced consciousness, folic acid deficiency, and the lack of timely thiamine treatment were risk factors for mortality.
Our results clearly show extreme variability in thiamine dosages and routes used in the management of WE. Measures should be implemented to ensure adherence to current guidelines and to correct potential nutritional deficits in patients with alcohol use disorders or other risk factors for WE.
尽管有指南和建议,但 Wernicke 脑病(WE)的治疗缺乏证据,导致临床实践存在差异。
鉴于 WE 治疗中硫胺素使用的总体信息缺乏,我们分析了来自一个大型、特征明确的多中心 WE 患者样本的数据,检查了硫胺素剂量;与使用不同剂量、频率和途径相关的因素;以及硫胺素治疗差异对结果的影响。
这项回顾性研究是对来自 21 个中心的 443 名患者的数据进行的,这些数据来自西班牙内科医师学会的全国登记处(2000 年至 2012 年)。采用出院代码和 Caine 标准诊断 WE,并分析与治疗相关的(硫胺素剂量、频率和给药途径)人口统计学、临床和结局变量。
我们发现 WE 治疗存在明显的差异,且高剂量静脉硫胺素给药的比例较低。373 名患者中有 78 名(20.9%)初始剂量超过 300mg/天。符合 Caine 标准或表现出经典 WE 三联征的患者更常接受肠外治疗。延迟诊断(住院后 24 小时)、诊断时符合超过两项 Caine 标准、精神状态改变和叶酸缺乏与不完全恢复显著相关。营养不良、意识障碍、叶酸缺乏和硫胺素治疗不及时是死亡的危险因素。
我们的结果清楚地表明,在 WE 管理中硫胺素剂量和途径的使用存在极大的差异。应采取措施确保遵守当前的指南,并纠正酒精使用障碍或其他 WE 危险因素患者的潜在营养不足。