Chen Guo
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, G12 8QQ, UK.
J Environ Manage. 2023 Dec 1;347:119029. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.119029. Epub 2023 Sep 24.
As the global carbon emission problem is getting more and more serious, the European Union has proposed the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) to prevent carbon leakage, which will have an impact on China's foreign trade. Based on this background and the problems of current research that ignores factors such as commodity prices, long-term impacts, intertemporal substitution analysis, and changes in national strategies for foreign exports, this paper propose a Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) model based on an evolutionary game as a dynamic recursive basis to study the impact of the CBAM on the Chinese manufacturing industry. For the industries mentioned in the CBAM, 18 affected sectors are collated, and a CGE model containing multiple blocks such as production, trade, and carbon emissions is built. Meanwhile, we establish an evolutionary game model with EU suppliers, manufacturers, and the government, allowing Chinese suppliers to compete with EU suppliers. Based on the above model, the impact of carbon tariff policies from 2020 to 2050 is studied. The results indicate that under the intra-EU competition condition, carbon tariffs will reduce the price of Chinese exports and slightly decrease China's real GDP, as well as the carbon emission intensity of 18 sectors and fossil energy. However, the impact of carbon tariffs on overall carbon emissions is small and is essentially a protective policy. In addition, the evolutionary game-based CGE model takes into account the dynamic strategies of both sides and is therefore less affected by carbon tariff shocks and recovers more quickly and more realistically. Finally, the article argues that the advantage of carbon tariffs for local suppliers is unsustainable and Chinese suppliers will still dominate, and local suppliers need more subsidies from the EU government. On the other hand, the Chinese government needs to implement a stricter carbon tax regime and export subsidies to improve the competitiveness of Chinese products in terms of green levels and price advantages. The purpose of this paper is to examine the quantitative impacts of CBAM on China's related manufacturing industries and strategies to maximize the benefits to both governments.
随着全球碳排放问题日益严峻,欧盟提出了碳边境调节机制(CBAM)以防止碳泄漏,这将对中国对外贸易产生影响。基于此背景以及当前研究存在忽视商品价格、长期影响、跨期替代分析和国家出口战略变化等因素的问题,本文提出一种基于演化博弈的可计算一般均衡(CGE)模型作为动态递归基础,以研究CBAM对中国制造业的影响。针对CBAM中提及的行业,梳理出18个受影响部门,并构建了一个包含生产、贸易和碳排放等多个模块的CGE模型。同时,建立了一个由欧盟供应商、制造商和政府参与的演化博弈模型,让中国供应商与欧盟供应商展开竞争。基于上述模型,研究了2020年至2050年碳关税政策的影响。结果表明,在欧盟内部竞争条件下,碳关税将降低中国出口产品价格,使中国实际GDP略有下降,同时18个部门的碳排放强度和化石能源也会有所降低。然而,碳关税对总体碳排放的影响较小,本质上是一种保护政策。此外,基于演化博弈的CGE模型考虑了双方的动态策略,因此受碳关税冲击的影响较小,恢复更快且更符合实际。最后,文章认为碳关税对本地供应商的优势不可持续,中国供应商仍将占据主导地位,本地供应商需要欧盟政府提供更多补贴。另一方面,中国政府需要实施更严格的碳税制度和出口补贴,以提高中国产品在绿色水平和价格优势方面的竞争力。本文旨在研究CBAM对中国相关制造业的量化影响以及使两国政府利益最大化的策略。