Department of Nuclear Medicine, Department of Psychiatry, Graduate School of Medical Science, Brain Korea 21 Project, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Department of Cognitive Science, Yonsei University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Sci Rep. 2023 Sep 27;13(1):16204. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-43291-8.
Artificial intelligence (AI) using deep learning approaches the capabilities of human experts in medical image diagnosis. However, due to liability issues in medical decisions, AI is often relegated to an assistant role. Based on this responsibility constraint, the effective use of AI to assist human intelligence in real-world clinics remains a challenge. Given the significant inter-individual variations in clinical decisions among physicians based on their expertise, AI needs to adapt to individual experts, complementing weaknesses and enhancing strengths. For this adaptation, AI should not only acquire domain knowledge but also understand the specific human experts it assists. This study introduces a meta-model for human-machine cooperation that first evaluates each expert's class-specific diagnostic tendencies using conditional probability, based on which the meta-model adjusts the AI's predictions. This meta-model was applied to ear disease diagnosis using otoendoscopy, highlighting improved performance when incorporating individual diagnostic characteristics, even with limited evaluation data. The highest accuracy was achieved by combining each expert's conditional probabilities with machine classification probability, using optimal weights specific to each individual's overall classification accuracy. This tailored model aims to mitigate potential misjudgments due to psychological effects caused by machine suggestions and to capitalize on the unique expertise of individual clinicians.
人工智能(AI)利用深度学习方法接近医学图像诊断领域人类专家的能力。然而,由于医疗决策中的责任问题,AI 通常被降级为辅助角色。基于这种责任约束,有效利用 AI 来辅助人类智能在现实临床中仍然是一个挑战。鉴于医生基于专业知识在临床决策方面存在显著的个体间差异,AI 需要适应个体专家,弥补弱点并增强优势。对于这种适应,AI 不仅需要获取领域知识,还需要理解它所辅助的特定人类专家。本研究引入了一种人机协作的元模型,该模型首先使用条件概率评估每个专家的特定类别诊断倾向,然后根据该元模型调整 AI 的预测。该元模型应用于耳疾病的耳镜诊断,即使使用有限的评估数据,也能突出考虑个体诊断特征后的性能提升。通过结合每个专家的条件概率和机器分类概率,并使用每个个体整体分类准确性的最优权重,实现了最高的准确性。这种定制模型旨在减轻由于机器建议引起的心理效应而导致的潜在误判,并利用个体临床医生的独特专业知识。