Sijing Li, Ying Jia, Jing Wu, Xiaoge Li, Ming Luo, Zhaoning Duan
Department of Gynecology, The First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University, Chongqing, China.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2023 Sep 13;10:1206856. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2023.1206856. eCollection 2023.
To probe into the additional role of ECC in the detection of cervical HSIL. The primary objective was to risk-stratify HSIL patients according to ECC so as to provide clinical suggestions for subsequent treatment.
Retrospective analysis of medical records for patients with HSIL. All patients underwent both ECC and cervical biopsy. According to the results of colposcopic targeted biopsy and ECC, the patients were divided into three groups: (1) ECC negative group (those whose colposcopic targeted biopsy indicated HSIL, but ECC indicated LSIL or chronic inflammation); (2) Only the ECC positive group (those whose ECC suggested HSIL, but colposcopic targeted biopsy showed LSIL or chronic inflammation); (3) ECC and biopsy positive group (those whose ECC and targeted biopsy were both HSIL). Chi-square test was used to analyze the differences of lesion residue and biopsy results after LEEP amongst the three groups.
A total of 1,146 medical records were analyzed. The diagnostic accuracy of ECC combined with colposcopic targeted biopsy for HSIL was higher than that of colposcopic biopsy alone (72.43% vs. 67.54%). When ECC indicated HSIL, the coincidence rate of ECC combined with colposcopic targeted biopsy and the histological pathology of LEEP was 86.25%, and the proportion of residual lesions after LEEP was 41.43%. When ECC and targeted biopsy both indicated HSIL, HSIL or worse lesions were confirmed in 90.68% of patients after surgery. Of these, 10.77% were confirmed as cervical invasive carcinoma. Moreover, the positive rate of LEEP resection margin and postoperative ECC in these patients was 43.48%.
ECC can improve the detection rate of cervical HSIL and reduce missed diagnosis. Also ECC can help clinicians predict the proportion of residual lesions after LEEP. This provides the gynecologists with a reference for the need to increase the depth of the procedure and the need to perform ECC for the residual cervical canal.
探讨宫颈管搔刮术(ECC)在宫颈高级别鳞状上皮内病变(HSIL)检测中的附加作用。主要目的是根据ECC对HSIL患者进行风险分层,以便为后续治疗提供临床建议。
回顾性分析HSIL患者的病历。所有患者均接受了ECC和宫颈活检。根据阴道镜靶向活检和ECC的结果,将患者分为三组:(1)ECC阴性组(阴道镜靶向活检提示HSIL,但ECC提示低级别鳞状上皮内病变[LSIL]或慢性炎症);(2)仅ECC阳性组(ECC提示HSIL,但阴道镜靶向活检显示LSIL或慢性炎症);(3)ECC和活检阳性组(ECC和靶向活检均为HSIL)。采用卡方检验分析三组患者leep术后病变残留及活检结果的差异。
共分析1146份病历。ECC联合阴道镜靶向活检对HSIL的诊断准确性高于单纯阴道镜活检(72.43%对67.54%)。当ECC提示HSIL时,ECC联合阴道镜靶向活检与leep组织病理学的符合率为86.25%,leep术后残留病变比例为41.43%。当ECC和靶向活检均提示HSIL时,90.68%的患者术后确诊为HSIL或更严重病变。其中,10.77%确诊为宫颈浸润癌。此外,这些患者leep切除切缘及术后ECC阳性率为43.48%。
ECC可提高宫颈HSIL的检出率,减少漏诊。此外,ECC有助于临床医生预测leep术后残留病变的比例。这为妇科医生增加手术深度及对残留宫颈管进行ECC的必要性提供了参考。