Division of Nephrology, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI; Division of Nephrology, Veterans Affairs Ann Arbor Health System, Ann Arbor, MI.
Arbor Research Collaborative for Health, Ann Arbor, MI.
Am J Kidney Dis. 2023 Dec;82(6):666-676. doi: 10.1053/j.ajkd.2023.04.008. Epub 2023 Aug 16.
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Cross-sectional studies have reported an association of chronic kidney disease-associated pruritus (CKD-aP) with adverse clinical events and patient-reported outcomes (PROs). We studied the longitudinal associations between changes in CKD-aP and clinical outcomes among patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis.
Prospective cohort study.
SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: 7,976 hemodialysis recipients across 21 countries in phases 4-6 (2009-2018) of the Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns Study (DOPPS) who had 2 CKD-aP assessments approximately 12 months apart.
Exposure status was based on the assessment of pruritis initially and again approximately 1 year later. Four groups were identified, including those with moderate or more severe pruritis only at the initial assessment (resolved), only at the second assessment (incident), at neither assessment (absent), or at both assessments (persistent).
Laboratory values and PROs ascertained at the initial assessment of pruritis and 1 year later.
Linear mixed model to investigate changes in laboratory values and PROs over the 1-year study period across the 4 exposure groups.
51% of patients had moderate to severe CKD-aP symptoms at either assessment (22% at both). The prevalences of depression, restless sleep, and feeling drained increased over the study period (+13%,+10%, and+14%, respectively) among patients with incident pruritus and decreased (-5%, -8%, and -12%, respectively) among patients with resolved pruritus. Minimal changes in PROs over time were observed for the absent and persistent groups. Changes over time in laboratory values (phosphorus, Kt/V) were not detected for either of these groups. Compared with patients with absent CKD-aP, the adjusted HRs for patients with persistent CKD-aP were 1.29 (95% CI, 1.09-1.53) for all-cause mortality, 1.17 (1.07-1.28) for all-cause hospitalization, and 1.48 (1.26-1.74) for cardiovascular events.
No interim evaluation of CKD-aP symptoms between the 2 assessments; potential selection bias from patients who died or were otherwise lost to follow-up before the second assessment.
CKD-aP symptoms are chronic, and these findings highlight the potential value of repeated assessment of this symptom using standardized approaches. Future research should systematically investigate potential causes of CKD-aP and options for its effective treatment.
PLAIN-LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Previous research has studied itching and its consequences in hemodialysis recipients only at a single time point. We surveyed 7,976 patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis to assess itching over a period of 1 year. We found that, among those experiencing itching at the initial assessment, more than half had persistent symptoms 1 year later. Those in whom itching developed during follow-up were more likely to experience depression, poor sleep, long recovery times after dialysis, and feeling faint or drained. These patients also rated their quality of life as poorer than those who did not experience itching. These findings emphasize the potential value of clinical detection of itching and the pursuit of effective treatments for patients receiving dialysis experiencing these symptoms.
横断面研究报告称,慢性肾脏病相关瘙痒(CKD-aP)与不良临床事件和患者报告结局(PROs)有关。我们研究了维持性血液透析患者中 CKD-aP 变化与临床结局之间的纵向关联。
前瞻性队列研究。
来自 DOPPS 研究(2009-2018 年)第 4-6 阶段的 21 个国家的 7976 名接受维持性血液透析的患者,他们大约在 12 个月内进行了两次 CKD-aP 评估。
暴露状态基于最初和大约 1 年后瘙痒评估的结果。确定了 4 个组,包括仅在初始评估时(缓解)、仅在第二次评估时(新发)、两次评估时均无(无)或两次评估时均有(持续)瘙痒症状中度或更严重的患者。
在初始瘙痒评估时和 1 年后确定的实验室值和 PROs。
线性混合模型用于研究 4 个暴露组在 1 年研究期间实验室值和 PROs 的变化。
51%的患者在任何一次评估中都有中度至重度 CKD-aP 症状(两次均有 22%)。新发瘙痒患者的抑郁、不安睡眠和乏力感在研究期间增加(分别增加+13%、+10%和+14%),缓解瘙痒患者的抑郁、不安睡眠和乏力感减少(分别减少-5%、-8%和-12%)。无瘙痒和持续瘙痒组 PROs 随时间的变化最小。这两个组的实验室值(磷、Kt/V)在随时间的变化都没有检测到。与无 CKD-aP 的患者相比,有持续 CKD-aP 的患者的全因死亡率、全因住院率和心血管事件的调整 HR 分别为 1.29(95%CI,1.09-1.53)、1.17(1.07-1.28)和 1.48(1.26-1.74)。
两次评估之间没有对 CKD-aP 症状进行中期评估;可能存在从死亡或在第二次评估前因其他原因失访的患者中存在选择偏倚。
CKD-aP 症状是慢性的,这些发现强调了使用标准化方法反复评估这种症状的潜在价值。未来的研究应系统地研究 CKD-aP 的潜在原因和有效治疗方法。
以前的研究仅在单个时间点研究瘙痒及其后果在血液透析患者中的表现。我们调查了 7976 名接受维持性血液透析的患者,以评估他们在 1 年内的瘙痒情况。我们发现,在最初评估时出现瘙痒的患者中,超过一半在 1 年后仍有持续症状。在随访期间出现瘙痒的患者更有可能出现抑郁、睡眠不佳、透析后恢复时间长、头晕或乏力等症状。这些患者也认为自己的生活质量比没有瘙痒的患者差。这些发现强调了临床检测瘙痒的潜在价值,以及为接受透析并出现这些症状的患者寻求有效治疗的重要性。