Chanelle Diaz (
Joseph Nwadiuko, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2023 Oct;42(10):1448-1455. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2023.00479.
The US is the world leader in imprisoning immigrants. Its mass immigration detention system emerged as an extension of mass incarceration, rooted in a legacy of racist US immigration and criminal laws. Immigration policy is a structural determinant of health that negatively affects the health of imprisoned immigrants, their families, and their communities. The systemic harms of "detention facilities," which we refer to as "immigration prisons," have been extensively documented, yet incrementalist reforms have failed to result in improved outcomes for immigrants. We argue that ending the practice of immigrant imprisonment is the most effective solution to mitigating its harms. Community-based programs are safer and less expensive than imprisonment, while also being effective at ensuring compliance with government requirements. We identify several priorities for researchers and policy makers to tackle the health inequities resulting from this structurally racist system. These include applying a critical, intersectional lens to studying the policies and practices that drive imprisonment, engaging affected communities in research and policy development, and creating an accountable and transparent system of data collection and release to inform health interventions. The reliance of the US on immigrant imprisonment is a policy choice with immense social and economic costs; dismantling it is critical to advancing health equity.
美国是全球监禁移民最多的国家。其大规模移民拘留系统是大规模监禁的延伸,其根源是美国移民和刑事立法的种族主义传统。移民政策是影响健康的结构性决定因素,它对被监禁移民及其家庭和社区的健康产生负面影响。“拘留设施”(我们称之为“移民监狱”)的系统性危害已得到广泛记录,但渐进式改革未能改善移民的结果。我们认为,结束移民监禁做法是减轻其危害的最有效办法。基于社区的方案比监禁更安全、更廉价,同时也能有效地确保遵守政府的要求。我们确定了研究人员和政策制定者需要解决的几个优先事项,以解决这一结构性种族主义制度造成的健康不平等问题。这些优先事项包括运用批判性、交叉性视角来研究推动监禁的政策和做法,让受影响的社区参与研究和政策制定,以及建立一个负责和透明的数据收集和发布系统,以提供信息来推动健康干预。美国依赖移民监禁是一种具有巨大社会和经济代价的政策选择;打破这一做法对于促进健康公平至关重要。