Wang Ziqing, Jamal Armaan, Wang Ryan, Dan Shozen, Kappagoda Shanthi, Kim Gloria, Palaniappan Latha, Long Jin, Singh Jaiveer, Srinivasan Malathi
The Stanford Center for Asian Health Research and Education (CARE), Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California.
Department of Statistics and Data Science, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.
AJPM Focus. 2022 Oct 29;2(1):100044. doi: 10.1016/j.focus.2022.100044. eCollection 2023 Mar.
Vaccination rates may be improved through culturally tailored messages, but little is known about them among disaggregated Asian American subgroups. We assessed the vaccination rates for key vaccines among these subgroups.
Using the National Health Interview Survey, we analyzed recent vaccination rates (2015-2018, =188,250) and trends (2006-2018) among Asians (Chinese [=3,165], Asian Indian [=3,525], Filipino [=3,656], other Asian [=5,819]) and non-Hispanic White adults (=172,085) for 6 vaccines (the human papillomavirus, hepatitis B, pneumococcal, influenza, tetanus-diphtheria [tetanus], and shingles vaccines). We controlled demographic, socioeconomic, and health-related variables in multivariable logistic regression and predicted marginal modeling analyses. We also computed vaccination rates among Asian American subgroups on the 2015-2018 National Health Interview Survey data stratified by foreign-born and U.S.-born status. We used Joinpoint regression to analyze trends in vaccination rates. All analyses were conducted in 2021 and 2022.
Among Asians, shingles (29.2%; 95% CI=26.6, 32.0), tetanus (53.7%; 95% CI=51.8, 55.6), and pneumococcal (53.8%; 95% CI=50.1, 57.4) vaccination rates were lower than among non-Hispanic Whites. Influenza (47.9%; 95% CI=46.2, 49.6) and hepatitis B (40.5%; 95% CI=39.0, 42.7) vaccination rates were similar or higher than among non-Hispanic Whites (48.4%; 95% CI=47.9, 48.9 and 30.7%; 95% CI=30.1, 31.3, respectively). Among Asians, we found substantial variations in vaccination rates and trends. For example, Asian Indian women had lower human papillomavirus vaccination rates (12.9%; 95% CI=9.1, 18.0) than all other Asian subgroups (Chinese: 37.9%; 95% CI=31.1, 45.2; Filipinos: 38.7%; 95% CI=29.9, 48.3; other Asians: 30.4%; 95% CI=24.8, 36.7) and non-Hispanic Whites (36.1%; 95% CI=34.8, 37.5). Being male, having lower educational attainment and income, having no health insurance or covered by public health insurance only, and lower frequency of doctor visits were generally associated with lower vaccine uptakes. Foreign-born Asian aggregate had lower vaccination rates than U.S.-born Asian aggregate for all vaccines except for influenza. We also found subgroup-level differences in vaccination rates between foreign-born and U.S.-born Asians. We found that (1) foreign-born Chinese, Asian Indians, and other Asians had lower human papillomavirus and hepatitis B vaccination rates; (2) foreign-born Chinese and Filipinos had lower pneumococcal vaccination rates; (3) foreign-born Chinese and Asian Indians had lower influenza vaccination rates; and (4) all foreign-born Asian subgroups had lower tetanus vaccination rates.
Vaccination rates and trends differed among Asian American subgroups. Culturally tailored messaging and interventions may improve vaccine uptakes.
通过文化定制信息可能会提高疫苗接种率,但对于细分的亚裔美国人亚群体,人们对此了解甚少。我们评估了这些亚群体中关键疫苗的接种率。
利用美国国家健康访谈调查,我们分析了亚洲人(华裔[=3165]、印度裔亚洲人[=3525]、菲律宾裔[=3656]、其他亚洲人[=5819])和非西班牙裔白人成年人(=172085)中6种疫苗(人乳头瘤病毒、乙型肝炎、肺炎球菌、流感、破伤风-白喉[破伤风]和带状疱疹疫苗)的近期接种率(2015 - 2018年,=188250)和趋势(2006 - 2018年)。我们在多变量逻辑回归和预测边际模型分析中控制了人口统计学、社会经济和健康相关变量。我们还根据2015 - 2018年美国国家健康访谈调查数据,按出生在国外和出生在美国的状况对亚裔美国人亚群体的疫苗接种率进行了计算。我们使用Joinpoint回归分析疫苗接种率的趋势。所有分析均在2021年和2022年进行。
在亚洲人中,带状疱疹(29.2%;95%置信区间=26.6,32.0)、破伤风(53.7%;95%置信区间=51.8,55.6)和肺炎球菌(53.8%;95%置信区间=50.1,57.4)疫苗接种率低于非西班牙裔白人。流感(47.9%;95%置信区间=46.2,49.6)和乙型肝炎(40.5%;95%置信区间=39.0,42.7)疫苗接种率与非西班牙裔白人相似或更高(分别为48.4%;95%置信区间=47.9,48.9和30.7%;95%置信区间=30.1,31.3)。在亚洲人中,我们发现疫苗接种率和趋势存在显著差异。例如,印度裔亚洲女性的人乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种率(12.9%;95%置信区间=9.1,18.0)低于所有其他亚洲亚群体(华裔:37.9%;95%置信区间=31.1,45.2;菲律宾裔:38.7%;95%置信区间=29.9,48.3;其他亚洲人:30.4%;95%置信区间=24.8,36.7)和非西班牙裔白人(36.1%;95%置信区间=34.8,37.5)。男性、教育程度和收入较低、没有医疗保险或仅由公共医疗保险覆盖以及看医生频率较低通常与较低的疫苗接种率相关。除流感外,出生在国外的亚洲人总体的疫苗接种率低于出生在美国的亚洲人总体。我们还发现出生在国外和出生在美国的亚洲人在疫苗接种率上存在亚群体层面的差异。我们发现:(1)出生在国外的华裔、印度裔亚洲人和其他亚洲人人乳头瘤病毒和乙型肝炎疫苗接种率较低;(2)出生在国外的华裔和菲律宾裔肺炎球菌疫苗接种率较低;(3)出生在国外的华裔和印度裔亚洲人流感疫苗接种率较低;(4)所有出生在国外的亚洲亚群体破伤风疫苗接种率较低。
亚裔美国人亚群体的疫苗接种率和趋势存在差异。文化定制的信息和干预措施可能会提高疫苗接种率。