Helmer Loreine M L, Dubois Leander, Lobbezoo Frank, de Lange Jan, Bosmans Judith E
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Academic Medical Centre of Amsterdam (AUMC) and Department of Orofacial Pain and Dysfunction, Academic Centre for Dentistry (ACTA), University of Amsterdam and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Meibergdreef 9, AZ Amsterdam ZO, Amsterdam, 1105, the Netherlands.
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Academic Medical Centre of Amsterdam (AUMC), Academic Centre for Dentistry (ACTA), University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Meibergdreef 9, AZ Amsterdam ZO, 1105, the Netherlands.
Heliyon. 2023 Sep 9;9(9):e19851. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e19851. eCollection 2023 Sep.
As treatment options for condylar fractures have comparable outcomes, getting insight into associated costs is a first step towards implementing value-based healthcare (VBH). Therefore, we described the actual costs of the different treatment options (surgical, conservative, and expectative treatment) for condylar fractures. We expected surgical treatment to be the most expensive treatment.
This is a cost-of-illness study, based on estimates from the literature. Firstly, care pathways of all treatment options were described. Secondly, the costs per step were calculated based on the literature and Dutch guidelines for economic evaluations in health care.
The direct treatment costs of surgical treatment (€3721 to €4040) are three to five times higher than conservative treatment (€730 to €1332). When lost productivity costs during the recovery period are included, costs of surgical treatment remain 1.5 times higher (€9511 to €9830 for surgical treatment and €6224 to €6826 for conservative treatment). The costs of expectative treatment (€5436) are lower than both other treatments.
The costs for surgical treatment are considerably higher than those for conservative or expectative treatment, mainly related to direct treatment cost. Future research should focus on the patients' perspective, to support implementation of VBH in treating condylar fractures.
由于髁突骨折的治疗方案具有相似的疗效,了解相关成本是实施基于价值的医疗保健(VBH)的第一步。因此,我们描述了髁突骨折不同治疗方案(手术、保守和期待治疗)的实际成本。我们预计手术治疗是最昂贵的治疗方式。
这是一项基于文献估计的疾病成本研究。首先,描述了所有治疗方案的护理路径。其次,根据文献和荷兰医疗保健经济评估指南计算每一步的成本。
手术治疗的直接治疗成本(3721欧元至4040欧元)比保守治疗(730欧元至1332欧元)高出三到五倍。如果将恢复期的生产力损失成本计算在内,手术治疗的成本仍高出1.5倍(手术治疗为9511欧元至9830欧元,保守治疗为6224欧元至6826欧元)。期待治疗的成本(5436欧元)低于其他两种治疗。
手术治疗的成本远高于保守或期待治疗,主要与直接治疗成本有关。未来的研究应关注患者的观点,以支持在髁突骨折治疗中实施VBH。