IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2023;31:4245-4255. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2023.3325132. Epub 2023 Oct 31.
The value of surface electromyograms (EMGs) lies in their potential to non-invasively probe the neuromuscular system. Whether muscle excitation may be accurately inferred from bipolar EMGs depends on how much the detected signal is both sensitive and specific to the excitation of the target muscle. While both are known to be a function of the inter-electrode distance (IED), specificity has been of long concern in the physiological literature. In contrast, sensitivity, at best, has been implicitly assumed. Here we provide evidence that the IED imposes a biophysical constraint on the sensitivity of surface EMG. From 20 healthy subjects, we tested the hypothesis that excessively reducing the IED limits EMGs' physiological content. We detected bipolar EMGs with IEDs varying from 5 mm to 50 mm from two skeletal muscles with distinct architectures, gastrocnemius and biceps brachii. Non-parametric statistics and Bayesian hierarchical modelling were used to evaluate the dependence of the onset of muscle excitation and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) on the IED. Experimental results revealed that IED critically affects the sensitivity of bipolar EMGs for both muscles-indeliberately reducing the IED yields EMGs that are not representative of the whole muscle, hampering validity. Simulation results substantiate the generalization of experimental results to small and large electrodes. Based on current and previous findings, we discuss a potentially valid procedure for defining the most appropriate IED for a single bipolar, surface recording-i.e., the distance from the electrode to the target muscle boundary may heuristically serve as a lower bound when choosing an IED.
表面肌电图 (EMG) 的价值在于其能够非侵入性地探测神经肌肉系统。双极 EMG 是否可以准确推断肌肉兴奋,取决于检测到的信号对目标肌肉兴奋的敏感程度和特异性。虽然两者都被认为是电极间距离 (IED) 的函数,但特异性一直是生理文献中长期关注的问题。相比之下,敏感性充其量只是被隐含假设。本文提供了证据表明,IED 对表面 EMG 的敏感性施加了一种生物物理限制。我们从 20 名健康受试者中测试了一个假设,即过度减小 IED 会限制 EMG 的生理内容。我们从具有不同结构的两块骨骼肌肉——腓肠肌和肱二头肌中检测到 IED 从 5 毫米到 50 毫米变化的双极 EMG。非参数统计和贝叶斯层次模型被用于评估肌肉兴奋的起始和信噪比 (SNR) 对 IED 的依赖性。实验结果表明,IED 对两种肌肉的双极 EMG 的敏感性都有至关重要的影响——故意减小 IED 会导致 EMG 不能代表整个肌肉,从而降低有效性。模拟结果证实了实验结果可以推广到小电极和大电极。基于当前和以前的发现,我们讨论了一种定义单个双极、表面记录最适当 IED 的潜在有效方法,即从电极到目标肌肉边界的距离可以作为选择 IED 的下限。