内侧β波段活动的不同表现反映了不同的视动反馈信号。
Different Faces of Medial Beta-Band Activity Reflect Distinct Visuomotor Feedback Signals.
机构信息
Institut de Neurosciences de la Timone, Unité Mixte de Recherche 7289, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Aix-Marseille Université, 13005 Marseille, France
Institut de Neurosciences des Systèmes, Unité Mixte de Recherche 7289, Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale, Aix-Marseille Université, 13005 Marseille, France.
出版信息
J Neurosci. 2023 Dec 6;43(49):8472-8486. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.2238-22.2023.
Beta-band (13-35 Hz) modulations following reward, task outcome feedback, and error have been described in cognitive and/or motor adaptation tasks. Observations from different studies are, however, difficult to conciliate. Among the studies that used cognitive response selection tasks, several reported an increase in beta-band activity following reward, whereas others observed increased beta power after negative feedback. Moreover, in motor adaptation tasks, an attenuation of the postmovement beta rebound follows a movement execution error induced by visual or mechanical perturbations. Given that kinematic error typically leads to negative task-outcome feedback (e.g., target missed), one may wonder how contradictory modulations, beta power decrease with movement error versus beta power increase with negative feedback, may coexist. We designed a motor adaptation task in which female and male participants experience varied feedbacks-binary success/failure feedback, kinematic error, and sensory-prediction error-and demonstrate that beta-band modulations in opposite directions coexist at different spatial locations, time windows, and frequency ranges. First, high beta power in the medial frontal cortex showed opposite modulations well separated in time when compared in success and failure trials; that is, power was higher in success trials just after the binary success feedback, whereas it was lower in the postmovement period compared with failure trials. Second, although medial frontal high-beta activity was sensitive to task outcome, low-beta power in the medial parietal cortex was strongly attenuated following movement execution error but was not affected by either the outcome of the task or sensory-prediction error. These findings suggest that medial beta activity in different spatio-temporal-spectral configurations play a multifaceted role in encoding qualitatively distinct feedback signals. Beta-band activity reflects neural processes well beyond sensorimotor functions, including cognition and motivation. By disentangling alternative spatio-temporal-spectral patterns of possible beta-oscillatory activity, we reconcile a seemingly discrepant literature. First, high-beta power in the medial frontal cortex showed opposite modulations separated in time in success and failure trials; power was higher in success trials just after success feedback and lower in the postmovement period compared with failure trials. Second, although medial frontal high-beta activity was sensitive to task outcome, low-beta power in the medial parietal cortex was strongly attenuated following movement execution error but was not affected by the task outcome or the sensory-prediction error. We propose that medial beta activity reflects distinct feedback signals depending on its anatomic location, time window, and frequency range.
β 波段(13-35 Hz)调制在奖励、任务结果反馈和错误后在认知和/或运动适应任务中已经被描述过。然而,来自不同研究的观察结果很难协调。在使用认知反应选择任务的研究中,有几项报告说在奖励后β 波段活动增加,而其他研究则观察到在负面反馈后β 功率增加。此外,在运动适应任务中,视觉或机械干扰引起的运动后β 回跳衰减后,运动执行错误。鉴于运动学误差通常会导致负面的任务结果反馈(例如,目标未命中),人们可能会想知道,运动后β 回跳的衰减与负面反馈后的β 功率增加如何可能共存。我们设计了一项运动适应任务,其中女性和男性参与者体验到不同的反馈——二进制成功/失败反馈、运动学误差和感觉预测误差——并证明了相反方向的β 波段调制在不同的空间位置、时间窗口和频率范围内共存。首先,与失败试验相比,在成功和失败试验中,当比较时,中额前皮质中的高β 功率显示出相反的调制,并且在时间上很好地分离;即,在二进制成功反馈后,成功试验中的功率更高,而在运动后时期与失败试验相比,功率较低。其次,尽管中额前皮质中的高β 活动对任务结果敏感,但运动执行错误后,中额顶叶皮质中的低β 功率强烈衰减,但不受任务结果或感觉预测误差的影响。这些发现表明,在不同的时空频谱配置中,中额β 活动在编码不同质量的反馈信号方面发挥着多方面的作用。β 波段活动反映了远超出感觉运动功能的神经过程,包括认知和动机。通过分离可能的β 振荡活动的替代时空频谱模式,我们协调了看似矛盾的文献。首先,在成功和失败试验中,当比较时,中额前皮质中的高β 功率显示出相反的调制,并且在时间上很好地分离;即,在二进制成功反馈后,成功试验中的功率更高,而在运动后时期与失败试验相比,功率较低。其次,尽管中额前皮质中的高β 活动对任务结果敏感,但运动执行错误后,中额顶叶皮质中的低β 功率强烈衰减,但不受任务结果或感觉预测误差的影响。我们提出,中额β 活动反映了不同的反馈信号,具体取决于其解剖位置、时间窗口和频率范围。