Hearty Pip, Canvin Krysia, Bellass Sue, Hampton Sarah, Wright Nat, Sheard Laura
Spectrum Community Health CIC, Wakefield, UK.
Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Health Justice. 2023 Oct 17;11(1):42. doi: 10.1186/s40352-023-00242-9.
People being held in prison are particularly vulnerable to Covid-19 infection, as places of detention are high-risk environments for spread of infection. Due to this risk, many prisons across the globe introduced measures to reduce the risk of Covid-19 transmission. The pandemic changed almost all aspects of prison life, including prison healthcare provision. We undertook a scoping review to understand what is known about the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the receipt and delivery of prison healthcare. This scoping review is part of a wider mixed-methods study focusing more specifically on the impact that Covid-19 had on prison healthcare delivery in England.
We conducted an international scoping review of peer-reviewed articles published between December 2019 and January 2022, across six electronic databases. We also conducted a hand search of key journals and the reference lists of included articles.
Twelve articles met our inclusion criteria. The articles focused primarily on prisons in high-income countries and mostly explored the impact that the pandemic had on the provision of drug treatment services. Some aspects of drug treatment services were more impacted than others, with those delivered by external providers and preparations for release particularly hindered. Whilst prison mental health services were purportedly available, there were changes regarding how these were delivered, with group therapies suspended and most consultations taking place using telehealth. The articles reported both digital and non-digital adaptations or innovations to prison healthcare services to ensure continued delivery. Collaboration between different agencies, such as the prison itself, healthcare providers, and non-governmental organisations, was key to facilitating ongoing provision of healthcare to people in prison.
Covid-19 impacted on prison healthcare internationally, but different treatment services were affected in disparate ways, both within and between countries. The published literature concentrates on the impact on drug treatment services. Prison healthcare providers rapidly adapted their processes to attempt to maintain service provision.
被关押在监狱中的人群特别容易感染新冠病毒,因为拘留场所是感染传播的高风险环境。鉴于这种风险,全球许多监狱都采取了措施来降低新冠病毒传播的风险。疫情几乎改变了监狱生活的方方面面,包括监狱医疗服务的提供。我们进行了一项范围审查,以了解关于新冠疫情对监狱医疗服务的接受和提供所产生影响的已知情况。这项范围审查是一项更广泛的混合方法研究的一部分,该研究更具体地关注新冠疫情对英格兰监狱医疗服务提供的影响。
我们对2019年12月至2022年1月期间发表在六个电子数据库中的同行评审文章进行了国际范围审查。我们还手动搜索了主要期刊以及纳入文章的参考文献列表。
12篇文章符合我们的纳入标准。这些文章主要关注高收入国家的监狱,并且大多探讨了疫情对药物治疗服务提供的影响。药物治疗服务的某些方面比其他方面受到的影响更大,由外部提供者提供的服务以及释放准备工作尤其受到阻碍。虽然监狱心理健康服务据称是可用的,但在提供方式上发生了变化,团体治疗暂停,大多数咨询通过远程医疗进行。文章报道了监狱医疗服务在数字和非数字方面的调整或创新,以确保服务的持续提供。不同机构之间的合作,如监狱本身、医疗服务提供者和非政府组织,是促进持续为监狱中的人员提供医疗服务的关键。
新冠疫情在国际上对监狱医疗产生了影响,但不同的治疗服务在国内和国家之间受到的影响各不相同。已发表的文献集中在对药物治疗服务的影响上。监狱医疗服务提供者迅速调整其流程,试图维持服务的提供。