Park Donghwi, Kwak Sang Gyu, Kim Saeyoon, Chang Min Cheol
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Daegu Fatima Hospital, Daegu, Korea.
Department of Medical Statistics, Daegu Catholic University School of Medicine, Daegu, Korea.
Korean J Fam Med. 2023 Nov;44(6):342-346. doi: 10.4082/kjfm.23.0093. Epub 2023 Oct 18.
With the growth of the Internet, social media platforms have emerged as major sources of medical information. We assessed the reliability, quality, and accuracy of the most-viewed YouTube videos containing information on the effect of vitamin C on the common cold.
The YouTube videos were searched on August 1, 2022, using the keywords: ("ascorbic acid" OR "vitamin C" OR "Sodium Ascorbate" OR "L-ascorbic") AND "common cold". The 30 most-viewed videos were included in our study. The reliability and quality of the videos were analyzed using modified DISCERN and Global Quality Scales, respectively. When the videos included at least one correct or inaccurate scientific statement about the effect of vitamin C on the common cold, they were classified as accurate or misleading videos, respectively; those without any pertinent information were considered neither accurate nor misleading. If a video contained both accurate and inaccurate statements, it was classified as misleading.
Of the 30 most-viewed videos, 73% were unreliable, and 67% contained misleading information and were of a poor quality. Of these 30 videos, 14 videos were produced and posted by customers who were not specialized in medicine or nutrition. Moreover, these videos were of significantly lower reliability, quality, and accuracy than those produced by nutrition or fitness channels or by medical or nutrition professionals.
The reliability, quality, and accuracy of videos uploaded by non-professionals were low. Therefore, video creators should upload reliable, high-quality videos to ensure the dissemination of accurate medical information.
随着互联网的发展,社交媒体平台已成为医学信息的主要来源。我们评估了YouTube上观看量最高的关于维生素C对普通感冒影响的视频的可靠性、质量和准确性。
于2022年8月1日在YouTube上使用关键词(“抗坏血酸”或“维生素C”或“抗坏血酸钠”或“L - 抗坏血酸”)和“普通感冒”进行搜索。我们的研究纳入了观看量最高的30个视频。分别使用改良的DISCERN量表和全球质量量表分析视频的可靠性和质量。当视频至少包含一条关于维生素C对普通感冒影响的正确或错误科学陈述时,它们分别被归类为准确或误导性视频;那些没有任何相关信息的视频被认为既不准确也不具有误导性。如果一个视频同时包含准确和不准确的陈述,则被归类为误导性视频。
在观看量最高的30个视频中,73%不可靠,67%包含误导性信息且质量较差。在这30个视频中,有14个是由非医学或营养专业的用户制作和发布的。此外,这些视频的可靠性、质量和准确性明显低于营养或健身频道或医学或营养专业人士制作的视频。
非专业人士上传的视频的可靠性、质量和准确性较低。因此,视频创作者应上传可靠、高质量的视频,以确保准确医学信息的传播。