Karimi Atefeh, Nelson Eliza L
Department of Psychology, Florida International University, Miami, FL, United States.
Front Psychol. 2023 Oct 2;14:1275325. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1275325. eCollection 2023.
Children with Down syndrome (DS) typically have motor and language needs. Improving function is a shared goal for the rehabilitation therapy team, however physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech-language pathology professionals treat patients differently. This difference in care may mask whereby changes in one domain (e.g., motor) can have seemingly unexpected effects on another domain (e.g., language).
This scoping review identified papers where motor and language data have been reported together in children with DS and reinterpreted findings from a developmental cascades lens.
Online databases were used to identify 413 papers published before October 2021 from which 33 papers were retained that reported both motor (gross and/or fine) and language (expressive and/or receptive) data in individuals with DS with a chronological age of 0-18 years.
The majority of papers (79%) that reported motor and language data in children with DS did not examine their link, while 12% analyzed motor-language links, but using a cross-sectional or retrospective design. Only three papers (9%) utilized a longitudinal design to examine predictive links.
Motor functioning and language functioning have often been reported together, but not analyzed together, in studies of children with DS. The few studies that did analyze motor-language links largely replicated findings from other developmental populations where motor gains were positively linked to language gains. Analyzing links between domains when such data is available is needed to fully characterize developmental cascades in DS and may have broad clinical implications.
唐氏综合征(DS)患儿通常有运动和语言方面的需求。改善功能是康复治疗团队的共同目标,然而物理治疗师、职业治疗师和言语语言病理专业人员对患者的治疗方式有所不同。这种护理差异可能掩盖了一个领域(如运动)的变化如何对另一个领域(如语言)产生看似意想不到的影响。
本范围综述确定了在DS患儿中同时报告运动和语言数据的论文,并从发育级联的角度重新解释研究结果。
使用在线数据库识别2021年10月之前发表的413篇论文,从中保留了33篇报告了年龄在0至18岁的DS个体的运动(粗大和/或精细)和语言(表达性和/或接受性)数据的论文。
在报告DS患儿运动和语言数据的大多数论文(79%)中,并未研究它们之间的联系,而12%的论文分析了运动与语言的联系,但采用的是横断面或回顾性设计。只有三篇论文(9%)采用纵向设计来研究预测性联系。
在DS患儿的研究中,运动功能和语言功能经常被同时报告,但并未一起分析。少数分析运动与语言联系的研究在很大程度上重复了其他发育人群的研究结果,即运动能力的提高与语言能力的提高呈正相关。当有此类数据时,分析各领域之间的联系对于全面描述DS的发育级联是必要的,并且可能具有广泛的临床意义。