Jantsch Adelson Guaraci, Burström Bo, Nilsson Gunnar H, Ponce de Leon Antônio
Instituto de Medicina Social, Rio de Janeiro State University, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Department of Global Public Health at the Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 Oct 18;3(10):e0000547. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0000547. eCollection 2023.
Lack of skilled human resources in primary care remains a major concern for policymakers in low- and middle-income countries. There is little evidence supporting the impact of residency training in family medicine in the quality of care, and it perpetuates misconceptions among policymakers that the provision of primary care can be easily done by any physician without special training. This article compares the risk of patients being hospitalized due to Ambulatory care sensitive conditions and the odds of having follow-up visits in primary care after hospital discharge, according to the type of their medical provider: (1) Generalists (reference), (2) Family physicians; and, (3) patients with no consultations prior to the event. Multilevel multivariate binomial regression models estimated the relative risks of a patient being hospitalized in a given month and the relative risks for the occurrence of a follow-up visit in primary care in a retrospective cohort of 636.640 patients between January 2013 and July 2018 in Rio de Janeiro. For all 14 conditions, there was a higher risk of hospitalization when patients had no consultation in primary care prior to the event. Except for Ear, Nose and Throat infections, patients seen by family physicians had a lower risk of being hospitalized, compared to patients seen by Generalists. Follow-up visits were more likely to happen among patients treated by family physicians for almost every condition analyzed. With two years of training in family medicine, Family physicians can reduce the risk of their patients being hospitalized and increase the likelihood of those patients having a follow-up consultation in primary care. Investments in residency training in family medicine should be made to fix the shortage of skilled physicians in primary care, reduce hospitalizations and improve quality and continuity of care.
初级保健领域缺乏专业人力资源仍是低收入和中等收入国家政策制定者主要关注的问题。几乎没有证据支持家庭医学住院医师培训对医疗质量的影响,而且这使政策制定者一直存在误解,认为任何未经专门培训的医生都能轻易提供初级保健服务。本文根据医疗服务提供者的类型,比较了因门诊敏感疾病住院的患者风险以及出院后在初级保健机构进行随访的几率:(1) 全科医生(参照组),(2) 家庭医生;以及,(3) 事件发生前未进行过会诊的患者。多水平多变量二项回归模型估计了2013年1月至2018年7月里约热内卢636,640例回顾性队列患者中,患者在给定月份住院的相对风险以及在初级保健机构进行随访的相对风险。对于所有14种疾病,事件发生前未在初级保健机构进行会诊的患者住院风险更高。除耳鼻喉感染外,与全科医生诊治的患者相比,家庭医生诊治的患者住院风险更低。对于几乎所有分析的疾病,家庭医生诊治的患者更有可能进行随访。经过两年的家庭医学培训,家庭医生可以降低患者住院风险,并增加这些患者在初级保健机构进行随访会诊的可能性。应投资于家庭医学住院医师培训,以解决初级保健领域专业医生短缺的问题,减少住院率,并提高医疗质量和连续性。