Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2023 Nov 1;94(11):852-856. doi: 10.3357/AMHP.6318.2023.
Wire strikes and in-air collisions with obstacles are a leading cause of accidents in the aerial application industry. While some of these collisions occur due to unseen obstacles, some pilots report being previously aware of the obstacles that they collide with. Whether or not pilots are aware of obstacles pre-collision is an important factor to inform methods of accident prevention. Final reports from the National Transportation Safety Board were analyzed for Part 137 Agricultural Operation accidents that took place between January 2020 and December 2022. A deeper analysis of cases that involved an in-air collision with an obstacle was performed, excluding cases that were attributable to an external cause (e.g., aerodynamic stall). The pilot's awareness of the obstacle pre-accident was inferred from accident narratives if available. Nearly half of all accidents ( = 45 of 107) involved an in-air collision with an obstacle (e.g., wire, tree, pole) as the defining event. In cases where pilot awareness of the obstacle was determinable through the accident report, over half of pilots ( = 21 of 39) had previously seen this obstacle yet still made contact with it. In-air obstacle collisions make up a substantial portion of accidents within Part 137 Agricultural Operations. Nearly half of pilots were already aware of the obstacle before collision, indicating that inadequate preparation in scoping the field is not a predominant driver of these events. Instead, these findings suggest that other factors including distractions, high task difficulty, and errors in decision-making may contribute.
线体撞击和与障碍物的空中碰撞是航空应用行业事故的主要原因。虽然其中一些碰撞是由于看不见的障碍物造成的,但一些飞行员报告说,他们之前已经意识到与他们发生碰撞的障碍物。飞行员在碰撞前是否意识到障碍物是告知事故预防方法的一个重要因素。对 2020 年 1 月至 2022 年 12 月期间发生的第 137 部分农业作业事故的国家运输安全委员会最终报告进行了分析。对涉及与障碍物空中碰撞的案例进行了更深入的分析,不包括归因于外部原因(例如空气动力失速)的案例。如果有可用的事故叙述,则可以从事故叙述中推断出飞行员在事故发生前对障碍物的了解程度。近一半的事故(=107 起中的 45 起)涉及与障碍物(例如线体、树木、电线杆)在空中发生碰撞,这是定义事件。在可以通过事故报告确定飞行员对障碍物的意识的情况下,超过一半的飞行员(=39 起中的 21 起)之前已经看到过这个障碍物,但仍与之发生了接触。空中障碍物碰撞构成第 137 部分农业作业事故的很大一部分。近一半的飞行员在碰撞前已经意识到障碍物,这表明在对作业区域进行范围界定方面准备不足并不是这些事件的主要驱动因素。相反,这些发现表明,其他因素,包括分心、高任务难度和决策错误,可能会造成影响。