Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; and Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, Oxford, UK.
Department of Psychology, University of Bath, Bath, UK.
Br J Psychiatry. 2024 Feb;224(2):47-54. doi: 10.1192/bjp.2023.132.
Forensic patients with psychosis often engage in violent behaviour. There has been significant progress in understanding risk factors for violence, but identification of causal mechanisms of violence is limited.
To develop a testable psychological framework explaining violence in psychosis - grounded in patient experience - to guide targeted treatment development.
We conducted in-depth interviews with 20 patients with psychosis using forensic psychiatric services across three regions in England. Interviews were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. People with lived experience contributed to the analysis.
Analysis of interviews identified several psychological processes involved in the occurrence of violence. Violence was the dominant response mode to difficulties that was both habitual and underpinned by rules that engaged and justified an attack. Violence was triggered by a trio of sensitivities to other people: sensitivity to physical threat, from which violence protected; sensitivity to social disrespect, by which violence increased status; and sensitivity to unfairness, by which violence delivered revenge. Violence was an attempt to regulate difficult internal states: intense emotions were released through aggression and violence was an attempt to escape being overwhelmed by voices, visions or paranoia. There were different patterns of emphasis across these processes when explaining an individual participant's offending behaviour.
The seven-factor model of violence derived from our analysis of patient accounts highlights multiple modifiable psychological processes that can plausibly lead to violence. The model can guide the research and development of targeted treatments to reduce violence by individuals with psychosis.
患有精神病的法医患者经常表现出暴力行为。虽然我们已经在理解暴力风险因素方面取得了重大进展,但对暴力行为的因果机制的认识仍然有限。
制定一个经过验证的心理学框架,解释精神病患者的暴力行为——基于患者的体验——以指导有针对性的治疗开发。
我们对英格兰三个地区的法医精神病服务机构的 20 名精神病患者进行了深入访谈。使用反思性主题分析对访谈进行了分析。有过亲身体验的人参与了分析。
对访谈的分析确定了暴力发生涉及的几个心理过程。暴力是对困难的主导反应模式,这种反应模式是习惯性的,并且受到参与和证明攻击合理性的规则的支持。暴力是由对他人的三重敏感性引发的:对身体威胁的敏感性,暴力可以保护这种敏感性;对社会不尊重的敏感性,通过这种敏感性,暴力可以提高地位;以及对不公平的敏感性,通过这种敏感性,暴力可以进行报复。暴力是试图调节困难的内部状态:通过攻击性释放强烈的情绪,而暴力是试图逃避被声音、幻觉或偏执所淹没的一种尝试。在解释个别参与者的犯罪行为时,这些过程中的强调模式是不同的。
我们从对患者描述的分析中得出的暴力的七因素模型突出了多个可改变的心理过程,这些过程可能会导致暴力行为。该模型可以指导针对精神病患者暴力行为的有针对性治疗的研究和开发。