Center for Public Health and Environmental Assessment, US Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC 27711, USA.
Center for Computational Toxicology and Exposure, US Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC 27711, USA.
Neurotoxicology. 2023 Dec;99:184-194. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2023.10.007. Epub 2023 Oct 20.
There is a need to assess compounds reliably and quickly for neurotoxicity (NT) and developmental neurotoxicity (DNT). Adverse outcome pathways (AOPs) enable the mapping of molecular events to an apical endpoint in a chemical agnostic manner and have begun to be applied in NT and DNT testing frameworks. We assessed the status of NT/DNT AOPs in the AOP-Wiki (ca. 2/1/23; https://aopwiki.org/), to characterize the state of AOP development, identify strengths and knowledge gaps, elucidate areas for improvement, and describe areas for future focus. AOPs in the Wiki database were assessed for inclusion of NT/DNT molecular events and endpoints, AOP development and endorsement, as well as the linkages of key neurodevelopmental processes with in vitro new approach methods (NAMs). This review found that 41 AOPs have been proposed detailing NT/DNT, of which eight were endorsed by working parties in OECD. Further, this review determined that learning and memory is included as an adverse outcome in eight NT/DNT AOPS, often without distinction regarding the varying forms of learning and memory, regional specification, temporal dynamics, or acquisition mechanisms involved. There is also an overlap with key events (KEs) and in vitro NAMs, which synaptogenesis appeared as a common process. Overall, progress on NT/DNT AOPs could be expanded, adding in modes of action that are missing, improvement in defining apical endpoints, as well as utilizing NAMs further to develop AOPs and identify gaps in current knowledge.
需要可靠和快速地评估化合物的神经毒性 (NT) 和发育神经毒性 (DNT)。 作用途径 (AOP) 能够以化学无知的方式将分子事件映射到顶端终点,并已开始应用于 NT 和 DNT 测试框架。 我们评估了 AOP-Wiki 中 NT/DNT AOP 的现状 (约 2/1/23; https://aopwiki.org/) ,以描述 AOP 开发的状态,确定优势和知识差距,阐明改进的领域,并描述未来关注的领域。 评估了 Wiki 数据库中的 AOP 是否包含 NT/DNT 分子事件和终点、AOP 开发和认可,以及关键神经发育过程与体外新方法 (NAM) 的联系。 本综述发现,已经提出了 41 个详细描述 NT/DNT 的 AOP,其中 8 个得到了经合组织工作组的认可。 此外,本综述确定了学习和记忆被包含为八个 NT/DNT AOP 的不良后果,通常没有区分不同形式的学习和记忆、区域特异性、时间动态或涉及的获取机制。 它还与关键事件 (KE) 和体外 NAMs 重叠,其中突触发生似乎是一个共同的过程。 总体而言,NT/DNT AOP 的进展可以扩大,增加缺失的作用模式,改进定义顶端终点,并进一步利用 NAMs 开发 AOP 并确定当前知识中的差距。