Cook Michael J, Puri Basant K
Vis a Vis Symposiums, Bury St. Edmunds, UK.
C.A.R., Cambridge, UK.
Int J Gen Med. 2023 Oct 18;16:4705-4718. doi: 10.2147/IJGM.S435975. eCollection 2023.
Epidemiological modelling of infectious diseases plays an important role in driving public health policy. Commonly used models are described, including those based on exponential growth (Laplace and related distributions); susceptible-infected-removed; the Gompertz distribution; and the skew-reflected-Gompertz distribution. These are all sensitive to the timing of peak infection. The development of a novel method for forecasting the number of deaths occurring during epidemics of infectious diseases is described.
The mathematical development of the authors' novel asymmetric difference model is detailed in this paper. Its predictions for mortality rates associated with the COVID-19 pandemic for 14 countries were compared with the corresponding published mortality data.
Forecasts by the asymmetric difference model of deaths from SARS-CoV-2 in different countries, actual recorded deaths to 30th June 2020, and corresponding errors included UK (42,700; 55,904; -24%); Poland (1490; 1444; +3%); Denmark (580; 605; -4%); Netherlands (6510; 6189; +5%); France (34,280; 29,836; +15%); Canada (1500; 8591; -78%); USA (44,540; 124,734; -64%); and Italy (22,020; 34,980; -37%). The model output was dependent upon forecast date accuracy for the peak of the disease outbreak. For Spain, the forecast date was one day early and for 10 (71%) countries the forecast peak occurred within seven days (inclusive) of the actual date.
Mortality prediction by the asymmetric difference model is relatively accurate. Furthermore, this new model does not appear to be as unduly sensitive to the timing of peak infection as other models. Indeed, its prediction of peak infection also appears to be relatively accurate.
传染病的流行病学建模在推动公共卫生政策方面发挥着重要作用。本文描述了常用的模型,包括基于指数增长的模型(拉普拉斯分布及相关分布);易感-感染-康复模型;冈珀茨分布;以及偏态反射冈珀茨分布。这些模型都对感染高峰的时间敏感。本文介绍了一种预测传染病流行期间死亡人数的新方法。
本文详细阐述了作者新型非对称差分模型的数学推导过程。将该模型对14个国家与新冠疫情相关死亡率的预测结果与相应的已公布死亡数据进行了比较。
非对称差分模型对不同国家新冠病毒死亡人数的预测、截至2020年6月30日的实际记录死亡人数以及相应误差如下:英国(42,700;55,904;-24%);波兰(1490;1444;+3%);丹麦(580;605;-4%);荷兰(6510;6189;+5%);法国(34,280;29,836;+15%);加拿大(1500;8591;-78%);美国(44,540;124,734;-64%);意大利(22,020;34,980;-37%)。模型输出结果取决于疾病爆发高峰预测日期的准确性。对于西班牙,预测日期早一天,对于10个(71%)国家,预测高峰出现在实际日期的七天内(含七天)。
非对称差分模型的死亡率预测相对准确。此外这个新模型似乎不像其他模型那样对感染高峰时间过度敏感。实际上,它对感染高峰的预测似乎也相对准确。