Rabbing Lillis, Lau Bjørn, Fostervold Knut Inge, Blenkinsopp John, Bjørkelo Brita
Doctoral Research Fellow,Norwegian Police University College, Norway; Department of Psychology, University of Oslo, Norway.
Department of Psychology, University of Oslo, Norway.
Psychol Rep. 2025 Oct;128(5):3898-3916. doi: 10.1177/00332941231207957. Epub 2023 Oct 30.
ObjectivesPolicing is recognized as a highly stressful occupation, encompassing stressors not commonly encountered in other fields. In response, police-specific stress scales have been developed and used when studying police work. Despite changes in the composition of police personnel, most studies examining police working conditions focus on sworn police officers (SPO), excluding employees without police education (EWPE). To advance research and practice on stress in the police, align results, and increase the possibilities for comparisons across studies using police-specific measures (PSMs) we conducted a psychometric evaluation of the two scales in the Police Stress Questionnaire (PSQ). We examined whether adding "Not Applicable" to the response scales would reduce vulnerability and make the PSQ more robust.MethodBased on a survey with a randomised sample ( = 560) of SPO and EWPE in the Norwegian Police, we tested the original factor structures of the PSQ through Confirmatory Factor Analysis including tests of factor structures from previous studies.ResultsFor all models, the indicators of fit indicated a poor fit with either our whole or stratified sample. The response choice 'Not Applicable' provided extended information for SPOs and EWPEs on the PSQ.ConclusionsTo promote aligning results and enabling comparisons across studies using the PSQ, we suggest treating the PSQ scales as formative indexes, rather than reflective scales. Adding "Not Applicable" to the response scale offers an influential elaboration of the PSQ with beneficial and extended information. Generalised studies of stress in the police should include the entire population working there.
目标
警务工作被认为是一项压力极大的职业,包含了其他领域通常不会遇到的压力源。作为应对措施,在研究警务工作时,已开发并使用了专门针对警察的压力量表。尽管警察队伍的构成发生了变化,但大多数关于警察工作条件的研究都集中在宣誓警察(SPO)身上,将没有接受过警察教育的雇员(EWPE)排除在外。为了推进警察压力方面的研究与实践,使研究结果保持一致,并增加使用专门针对警察的测量工具(PSM)进行跨研究比较的可能性,我们对《警察压力问卷》(PSQ)中的两个量表进行了心理测量评估。我们研究了在回答量表中增加“不适用”选项是否会降低易感性并使PSQ更具稳健性。
方法
基于对挪威警察中SPO和EWPE的随机样本( = 560)进行的一项调查,我们通过验证性因素分析测试了PSQ的原始因素结构,包括对先前研究中的因素结构进行测试。
结果
对于所有模型,拟合指标表明无论是在我们的整个样本还是分层样本中,拟合度都很差。“不适用”这一回答选项为PSQ上的SPO和EWPE提供了更多信息。
结论
为了促进使用PSQ的研究结果保持一致并便于跨研究进行比较,我们建议将PSQ量表视为构成性指标,而非反映性量表。在回答量表中增加“不适用”选项为PSQ提供了有影响力的详细阐述,并带有有益且更多的信息。对警察压力的一般性研究应涵盖在那里工作的全体人员。