Department of Neurosurgery and Brain Metastasis Center, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New York.
Department of Neurosurgery, New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical College, New York.
JAMA Netw Open. 2023 Oct 2;6(10):e2340654. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.40654.
Adjuvant stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) enhances the local control of resected brain metastases (BrM). However, the risks of local failure (LF) and potential for posttreatment adverse radiation effects (PTRE) after early postoperative adjuvant SRS have not yet been established.
To evaluate whether adjuvant SRS delivered within a median of 14 days after surgery is associated with improved LF without a concomitant increase in PTRE.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This prospective cohort study examines a clinical workflow (RapidRT) that was implemented from 2019 to 2022 to deliver SRS to surgical patients within a median of 14 days, ensuring all patients were treated within 30 days postoperatively. This prospective cohort was compared with a historical cohort (StanRT) of patients with BrM resected between 2013 and 2019 to assess the association of the RapidRT workflow with LF and PTRE. The 2 cohorts were combined to identify optimal SRS timing, with a median follow-up of 3.3 years for survivors.
Timing of adjuvant SRS (14, 21, and 30 days postoperatively).
LF and PTRE, according to modified Response Assessment in Neuro-Oncology Brain Metastases criteria.
There were 438 patients (265 [60.5%] female patients; 23 [5.3%] Asian, 27 [6.2%] Black, and 364 [83.1%] White patients) with a mean (SD) age of 62 (13) years; 377 were in the StanRT cohort and 61 in the RapidRT cohort. LF and PTRE rates at 1 year were not significantly different between RapidRT and StanRT cohorts. Timing of SRS was associated with radiographic PTRE. Patients receiving radiation within 14 days had the highest 1-year PTRE rate (18.08%; 95% CI, 8.31%-30.86%), and patients receiving radiation between 22 and 30 days had the lowest 1-year PTRE rate (4.10%; 95% CI, 1.52%-8.73%; P = .03). LF rates were highest for patients receiving radiation more than 30 days from surgery (10.65%; 95% CI, 6.90%-15.32%) but comparable for patients receiving radiation within 14 days, between 15 and 21 days, and between 22 and 30 days (≤14 days: 5.12%; 95% CI, 0.86%-15.60%; 15 to ≤21 days: 3.21%; 95% CI, 0.59%-9.99%; 22 to ≤30 days: 6.58%; 95% CI, 3.06%-11.94%; P = .20).
In this cohort study of adjuvant SRS timing following surgical resection of BrM, the optimal timing for adjuvant SRS appears to be within 22 to 30 days following surgery. The findings of this study suggest that this timing allows for a balanced approach that minimizes the risks associated with LF and PTRE.
辅助立体定向放射外科(SRS)可增强切除脑转移瘤(BrM)的局部控制。然而,术后早期辅助 SRS 后局部失败(LF)的风险和潜在的治疗后不良反应(PTRE)尚未确定。
评估手术后中位数 14 天内接受辅助 SRS 是否与改善 LF 相关,而不会增加 PTRE。
设计、地点和参与者:本前瞻性队列研究检查了一种临床工作流程(RapidRT),该工作流程于 2019 年至 2022 年实施,旨在中位数 14 天内为手术患者提供 SRS,确保所有患者都在术后 30 天内接受治疗。该前瞻性队列与 2013 年至 2019 年间切除 BrM 的历史队列(StanRT)进行了比较,以评估 RapidRT 工作流程与 LF 和 PTRE 的相关性。两个队列合并以确定最佳 SRS 时间,幸存者的中位随访时间为 3.3 年。
辅助 SRS 的时间(术后 14、21 和 30 天)。
根据改良的神经肿瘤学脑转移瘤反应评估标准,评估 LF 和 PTRE。
共有 438 名患者(265 名女性患者;23 名亚裔患者,27 名黑人患者和 364 名白人患者),平均年龄(标准差)为 62(13)岁;377 名患者在 StanRT 队列,61 名患者在 RapidRT 队列。RapidRT 队列和 StanRT 队列的 1 年 LF 和 PTRE 率无显著差异。SRS 的时间与放射性 PTRE 相关。在 14 天内接受放疗的患者 1 年 PTRE 率最高(18.08%;95%CI,8.31%-30.86%),而在 22 至 30 天内接受放疗的患者 1 年 PTRE 率最低(4.10%;95%CI,1.52%-8.73%;P = .03)。接受放疗时间超过手术 30 天的患者 LF 率最高(10.65%;95%CI,6.90%-15.32%),但接受放疗时间为 14 天、15 至 21 天和 22 至 30 天的患者 LF 率相当(≤14 天:5.12%;95%CI,0.86%-15.60%;15 至≤21 天:3.21%;95%CI,0.59%-9.99%;22 至≤30 天:6.58%;95%CI,3.06%-11.94%;P = .20)。
在这项关于脑转移瘤切除术后辅助 SRS 时机的队列研究中,辅助 SRS 的最佳时机似乎是在手术后 22 至 30 天。这项研究的结果表明,这种时间安排可以采取平衡的方法,最大限度地降低 LF 和 PTRE 相关的风险。