Health Research and Technology Transfer Directorate, SNNPR Health Bureau, Hawassa, Sidama, Ethiopia.
Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Directorate, SNNPR Health Bureau, Hawassa, Sidama, Ethiopia.
PLoS One. 2023 Oct 31;18(10):e0293722. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0293722. eCollection 2023.
School closures in response to the COVID-19 impacted children's education, protection, and wellbeing. After understanding these impacts and that children were not super spreaders, countries including Ethiopia decided to reopen schools with specified preconditions. But when deciding to reopen schools, the benefits and risks across education, public health and socio-economic factors have to be evaluated. However, there was information gap on status of schools as per preconditions. Hence, this study was designed to investigate status of schools in Southern Ethiopia.
School based cross-sectional study was conducted in October 2020 in Southern Ethiopia. Sample of 430 schools were included. National school reopening guideline was used to develop checklist for assessment. Data was collected by public health experts at regional emergency operation center. Descriptive analysis was performed to summarize data.
A total of 430 schools were included. More than two thirds, 298 (69.3%), of schools were from rural areas while 132 (30.7%) were from urban settings. The general infection prevention and water, sanitation and hygiene (IPC-WASH) status of schools were poor and COVID-19 specific preparations were inadequate to meet national preconditions to reopen schools during the pandemic. Total score from 24 items observed ranged from 3 to 22 points with mean score of 11.75 (SD±4.02). No school scored 100% and only 41 (9.5%) scored above 75% while 216 (50.2%%) scored below half point that is 12 items.
Both the basic and COVID-19 specific IPC-WASH status of schools were inadequate to implement national school reopening preconditions and general standards. Some of strategies planned to accommodate teaching process and preconditions maximized inequalities in education. Although COVID-19 impact lessened due to vaccination and other factors, it is rational to consider fulfilling water and basic sanitation facilities to schools to prevent communicable diseases of public health importance.
为应对 COVID-19 而关闭学校对儿童的教育、保护和福利造成了影响。在了解到这些影响,以及儿童并非超级传播者之后,包括埃塞俄比亚在内的多个国家决定在满足特定前提条件的情况下重新开放学校。但是,在决定重新开放学校时,必须评估教育、公共卫生和社会经济因素方面的利益和风险。然而,关于学校满足前提条件的现状,存在信息空白。因此,本研究旨在调查埃塞俄比亚南部学校的现状。
本研究于 2020 年 10 月在埃塞俄比亚南部开展了一项基于学校的横断面研究。共纳入了 430 所学校。使用国家学校重新开放指南制定了评估清单。数据由地区应急行动中心的公共卫生专家收集。采用描述性分析对数据进行总结。
共纳入 430 所学校。其中 298 所(69.3%)来自农村地区,132 所(30.7%)来自城市地区,超过三分之二的学校为农村地区。学校的一般感染预防和水、环境卫生与个人卫生(IPC-WASH)状况较差,且针对 COVID-19 的特定准备工作不足以满足国家在大流行期间重新开放学校的前提条件。观察到的 24 项总分范围为 3 至 22 分,平均得分为 11.75(SD±4.02)。没有一所学校的得分达到 100%,只有 41 所(9.5%)的得分高于 75%,而 216 所(50.2%)的得分低于一半,即 12 项。
学校的基本和针对 COVID-19 的 IPC-WASH 状况均不足以实施国家学校重新开放的前提条件和总体标准。一些旨在满足教学需求和前提条件的策略最大限度地加剧了教育方面的不平等。尽管由于疫苗接种和其他因素,COVID-19 的影响有所减弱,但考虑到为学校提供水和基本卫生设施以预防具有公共卫生重要性的传染病是合理的。