Jones M, Quenby S, Odendaal J
Division of Biomedical Sciences, Clinical Sciences Research Laboratories, Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK.
University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire, Coventry, UK.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2023 Nov 9;10:23821205231210629. doi: 10.1177/23821205231210629. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
The dramatic global impact of the coronavirus pandemic has increased consideration on epidemiological progressions of pandemics. Measures implemented to reduce viral transmission have been largely historical, comparable in nature with the 1918 and 2009 influenza pandemics, demonstrating the importance of clinicians' awareness on historical pandemics. Despite this, literature suggests medical students' knowledge on previous pandemics is poor.
This study aims to gather stakeholder information from UK medical students on the importance of including the history of pandemics in the medical school curriculum.
A cross-sectional cohort study conducted via a mixed question type online survey was distributed to all UK medical schools to explore stakeholder views. Grounded theory emergent coding was used to generate themes to free-text answers and SPSS and Excel were used to analyse quantitative data using pivot tables and Fishers exact tests.
Two hundred and forty-one students consented to take part from eight medical schools in the UK with 98% of these students completing the questionnaire. 34% of students reported having teaching on pandemics with 78% of students stating it would be beneficial. Knowledge was poor with 5.7% of students achieving 100% on knowledge-based questions. 72% of students believed that learning about the history of medicine would be beneficial with 87% of these students referring to 'benefiting (the) future' in their answers. Additionally, 79% of students thought it would be beneficial to learn about historical pandemics with reference to the current COVID-19 pandemic.
To date, this is the only UK based study assessing stakeholders' views on including the history of pandemics in the medical school curriculum. Our findings demonstrate that medical students wish to have more historical content included in their degree to better prepare tomorrow's doctors for situations that may occur when history repeats itself.
冠状病毒大流行对全球产生的巨大影响促使人们更多地关注大流行的流行病学进展。为减少病毒传播而采取的措施在很大程度上是基于历史经验的,本质上与1918年和2009年的流感大流行类似,这表明临床医生了解历史上的大流行具有重要意义。尽管如此,文献表明医学生对以往大流行的了解程度较低。
本研究旨在收集英国医学生关于在医学院课程中纳入大流行历史的重要性的利益相关者信息。
通过混合问题类型的在线调查对英国所有医学院进行横断面队列研究,以探讨利益相关者的观点。采用扎根理论的涌现编码方法对自由文本答案生成主题,并使用SPSS和Excel通过数据透视表和费舍尔精确检验分析定量数据。
来自英国8所医学院的241名学生同意参与,其中98%的学生完成了问卷。34%的学生表示接受过有关大流行的教学,78%的学生表示这将是有益的。学生的相关知识水平较低,只有5.7%的学生在基于知识的问题上得满分。72%的学生认为学习医学史会有好处,其中87%的学生在回答中提到“对未来有益”。此外,79%的学生认为结合当前的COVID-19大流行了解历史上的大流行会有好处。
迄今为止,这是唯一一项评估利益相关者对在医学院课程中纳入大流行历史的观点的英国研究。我们的研究结果表明,医学生希望在其学位课程中纳入更多历史内容,以便让未来的医生更好地应对历史重演时可能出现的情况。