Wang Xiaowa, Shi Liqun, Wang Xufei, Wang Lan
Institute of Modern Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Ion-beam Application (MOE), Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
Transl Cancer Res. 2023 Oct 31;12(10):2545-2555. doi: 10.21037/tcr-23-1107. Epub 2023 Oct 17.
To overcome proton therapy limitations [low linear energy transfer (LET) radiation with a relative biological effectiveness (RBE) typically ranging from 1.1 to 1.2], radiosensitization techniques can be employed to increase the radiosensitivity of tumor cells and improve the effectiveness of radiation therapy. In this study, we suggest using a boron-based medium to overcome the biological limitations of proton therapy. By inducing the hydrogen-boron fusion reaction (p + B → 3α) of incident protons and capturing thermal neutrons [B + n → Li (0.84 MeV) + He (1.47 MeV) + γ (0.477 MeV)], high LET α particles can be released. We propose a "ternary" radiotherapy model to enhance the biological effect of proton therapy.
Using Monte Carlo simulation, the possibility of interacting low-energy proton beams with B and thermal neutrons with B to produce α particles with higher RBE to enhance the biological effect of proton radiotherapy were investigated. And the number and location of α particles and thermal neutrons produced by the interaction of protons with natural boron had also been studied.
Under the basic principle of the "ternary" radiotherapy model, comparative analyses of neutrons and α particles produced by proton beams of different energies incident on the phantoms, which were composed of boron isotopes of different concentrations in proportion to the phantoms, have shown that the α particle yield decreased with decreasing boron doping concentration, whereas the neutron yield increased with decreasing boron doping concentration. The distribution of thermal neutrons and α particles in the longitudinal direction of the proton beam were also studied, and it was found that the number of α particles produced was high at high boron concentrations, and the locations of α and thermal neutrons were close to the treatment target.
The proton therapy ternary model is theoretically feasible from the perspective of mathematical analysis and Monte Carlo simulation experiments.
为克服质子治疗的局限性[低传能线密度(LET)辐射,相对生物效应(RBE)通常在1.1至1.2之间],可采用放射增敏技术来提高肿瘤细胞的放射敏感性并改善放射治疗效果。在本研究中,我们建议使用基于硼的介质来克服质子治疗的生物学局限性。通过诱导入射质子的氢硼聚变反应(p + B → 3α)并俘获热中子[B + n → Li(0.84兆电子伏特)+ He(1.47兆电子伏特)+ γ(0.477兆电子伏特)],可以释放高LET的α粒子。我们提出一种“三元”放射治疗模型以增强质子治疗的生物学效应。
利用蒙特卡罗模拟,研究了低能质子束与硼相互作用以及热中子与硼相互作用产生具有更高RBE的α粒子以增强质子放射治疗生物学效应的可能性。还研究了质子与天然硼相互作用产生的α粒子和热中子的数量及位置。
在“三元”放射治疗模型的基本原理下,对不同能量质子束入射到由不同浓度硼同位素按比例组成的模体上产生的中子和α粒子进行比较分析,结果表明α粒子产额随硼掺杂浓度降低而减少,而中子产额随硼掺杂浓度降低而增加。还研究了热中子和α粒子在质子束纵向的分布,发现硼浓度高时产生的α粒子数量多,且α粒子和热中子的位置靠近治疗靶点。
从数学分析和蒙特卡罗模拟实验的角度来看,质子治疗三元模型在理论上是可行的。