Nerurkar Nupur Kapoor, Nagree Zainab, Malik Enu
Bombay Hospital Voice and Swallowing Centre, 2nd Floor MRC, Mumbai, Maharashtra India.
Bombay Hospital & Medical Research Centre, Mumbai, Maharashtra India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023 Dec;75(4):2741-2746. doi: 10.1007/s12070-023-03837-8. Epub 2023 May 10.
Our study aims to ascertain the results of speech therapy and surgery in patients who desire pitch alteration. Typically, patients desirous of an increase in their vocal pitch are male-to-female transpersons, and patients desirous of a drop in their pitch are puberphonia patients. This is a 3-year retrospective study of patients who have been operated for pitch alteration. This is a study of seven patients each of Wendlers glottoplasty (WG) and relaxation laryngeal framework surgery (RLFS). The records were reviewed for the preoperative and the 1-year post-operative fundamental frequency (FO), patient subjective satisfaction score (PSSS), and healing time. A total of 7/35 patients of puberphonia underwent RLFS in which the average preoperative F0 was 216 Hz and 1-year post-operative F0 was 114 Hz ( 0.004). The average pre- and post-operative PSSS was 4 and 9 ( 0.0004). Patients of WG had an average preoperative F0 of 153 Hz and 1-year post-operative F0 of 223 Hz ( 0.0005). The average pre and 1-year postoperative PSSS was 4 and 8 ( 0.002). The average healing time was 3 weeks 4 days in the RLFS patients and 8 weeks 5 days for WG patients. The results of RFLS yielded a high PSSS with a pitch drop of more than 100 Hz. The results of WG yielded an increase in the pitch of 70 Hz with a good PSSS. The average healing time taken following WG was double the time taken for RFLS.
我们的研究旨在确定有音高改变需求的患者接受言语治疗和手术的结果。通常,希望提高嗓音音高的患者是男变女的跨性别者,而希望降低音高的患者是青春期后嗓音异常患者。这是一项对接受音高改变手术的患者进行的为期3年的回顾性研究。该研究纳入了7例接受温德勒声门成形术(WG)和7例接受喉框架松弛手术(RLFS)的患者。对术前和术后1年的基频(FO)、患者主观满意度评分(PSSS)以及愈合时间的记录进行了回顾。共有7/35例青春期后嗓音异常患者接受了RLFS,其中术前平均F0为216Hz,术后1年F0为114Hz(P<0.004)。术前和术后的平均PSSS分别为4和9(P<0.0004)。接受WG的患者术前平均F0为153Hz,术后1年F0为223Hz(P<0.0005)。术前和术后1年的平均PSSS分别为4和8(P<0.002)。RLFS患者的平均愈合时间为3周4天,WG患者为8周5天。RLFS的结果显示PSSS较高,音高下降超过100Hz。WG的结果显示音高增加70Hz,PSSS良好。WG后的平均愈合时间是RLFS的两倍。