Kjällman M, Nylén O, Hansén M
Scand J Rheumatol. 1986;15(3):265-71. doi: 10.3109/03009748609092590.
Over the period 1976-83 the clinical records were studied of 150 patients with the diagnosis of confirmed or possible sacro-iliitis. All these patients had pathologic sacro-iliac indices on quantitative bone scintigraphy. The most recent radiographs of the sacro-iliac joints were examined by two radiologists independently of each other. 103 (68%) patients with a mean duration of symptoms of 6.7 years, had normal radiographs. The frequency of HLA B27 in this group was only 27%, contrary to the expected 90-100% in an ankylosing spondylitis (AS) population. In a follow-up study, 30 patients, who in 1976-79 had normal sacro-iliac joint X-rays, were further investigated. The mean duration of symptoms was 11.3 years. 21 patients (70%) still had normal radiographs of their sacro-iliac joints and the HLA B27 frequency in this group was 28%. Normal radiographs of the sacro-iliac joints, in spite of the long duration of symptoms together with a low frequency of HLA B27, makes the diagnosis of AS most unlikely. This indicates a low specificity for quantitative sacro-iliac scintigraphy in the early diagnosis of AS. In the follow-up study, Calin's screening test for AS was included and was also found to have a low specificity.
在1976年至1983年期间,对150例确诊或疑似骶髂关节炎患者的临床记录进行了研究。所有这些患者在定量骨闪烁扫描中均有病理骶髂关节指数。两名放射科医生彼此独立地检查了骶髂关节的最新X光片。103例(68%)患者平均症状持续时间为6.7年,其X光片正常。该组中HLA B27的频率仅为27%,与强直性脊柱炎(AS)人群中预期的90%-100%相反。在一项随访研究中,对1976年至1979年骶髂关节X光片正常的30例患者进行了进一步调查。平均症状持续时间为11.3年。21例(70%)患者的骶髂关节X光片仍正常,该组中HLA B27的频率为28%。尽管症状持续时间长且HLA B27频率低,但骶髂关节X光片正常使得AS的诊断极不可能。这表明定量骶髂关节闪烁扫描在AS早期诊断中的特异性较低。在随访研究中,纳入了卡林AS筛查试验,发现其特异性也较低。