Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Institute for Women's Health, University College London, London, UK.
School of Biomedical Engineering and Imaging Sciences (BMEIS), King's College London, London, UK.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2024 Feb;103(2):322-333. doi: 10.1111/aogs.14711. Epub 2023 Nov 20.
Fetal surgery for open spina bifida (OSB) requires comprehensive preoperative assessment using imaging for appropriate patient selection and to evaluate postoperative efficacy and complications. We explored patient access and conduct of fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for prenatal assessment of OSB patients eligible for fetal surgery. We compared imaging acquisition and reporting to the International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology MRI performance guidelines.
We surveyed access to fetal MRI for OSB in referring fetal medicine units (FMUs) in the UK and Ireland, and two NHS England specialist commissioned fetal surgery centers (FSCs) at University College London Hospital, and University Hospitals KU Leuven Belgium. To study MRI acquisition protocols, we retrospectively analyzed fetal MRI images before and after fetal surgery for OSB.
MRI for fetal OSB was accessible with appropriate specialists available to supervise, perform, and report scans. The average time to arrange a fetal MRI appointment from request was 4 ± 3 days (range, 0-10), the average scan time available was 37 ± 16 min (range, 20-80 min), with 15 ± 11 min (range, 0-30 min) extra time to repeat sequences as required. Specific MRI acquisition protocols, and MRI reporting templates were available in only 32% and 18% of units, respectively. Satisfactory T2-weighted (T2W) brain imaging acquired in three orthogonal planes was achieved preoperatively in all centers, and 6 weeks postoperatively in 96% of FSCs and 78% of referring FMUs. However, for T2W spine image acquisition referring FMUs were less able to provide three orthogonal planes presurgery (98% FSC vs. 50% FMU, p < 0.001), and 6 weeks post-surgery (100% FSC vs. 48% FMU, p < 0.001). Other standard imaging recommendations such as T1-weighted (T1W), gradient echo (GE) or echoplanar fetal brain and spine imaging in one or two orthogonal planes were more likely available in FSCs compared to FMUs pre- and post-surgery (p < 0.001).
There was timely access to supervised MRI for OSB fetal surgery assessment. However, the provision of images of the fetal brain and spine in sufficient orthogonal planes, which are required for determining eligibility and to determine the reversal of hindbrain herniation after fetal surgery, were less frequently acquired. Our evidence suggests the need for specific guidance in relation to fetal MRI for OSB. We propose an example guidance for MRI acquisition and reporting.
开放性脊柱裂(OSB)的胎儿手术需要使用影像学进行全面的术前评估,以选择合适的患者,并评估术后效果和并发症。我们探讨了英国和爱尔兰的胎儿医学单位(FMU)中用于 OSB 患者产前评估的胎儿磁共振成像(MRI)的患者获得途径和实施情况,该评估适用于胎儿手术。我们比较了成像采集和报告与国际妇产科超声学会(ISUOG)MRI 性能指南的一致性。
我们调查了英国和爱尔兰的胎儿医学单位(FMU)以及英国伦敦大学学院医院和比利时鲁汶天主教大学医院两个 NHS 英格兰专科委托胎儿外科中心(FSC)获得 OSB 胎儿 MRI 的途径。为了研究 MRI 采集方案,我们回顾性分析了 OSB 胎儿手术前后的胎儿 MRI 图像。
有合适的专家可以监督、进行和报告扫描,因此可以获得用于胎儿 OSB 的 MRI。从请求到安排胎儿 MRI 预约的平均时间为 4 ± 3 天(范围,0-10 天),平均可利用的扫描时间为 37 ± 16 分钟(范围,20-80 分钟),需要额外重复序列时则需要 15 ± 11 分钟(范围,0-30 分钟)。只有 32%的单位提供特定的 MRI 采集方案,18%的单位提供 MRI 报告模板。所有中心均能在术前获得满意的三个正交平面的 T2 加权(T2W)脑成像,96%的 FSC 和 78%的转诊 FMU 在术后 6 周时获得该成像。然而,对于 T2W 脊柱图像采集,转诊 FMU 术前提供三个正交平面的能力较差(98%的 FSC 与 50%的 FMU,p < 0.001),术后 6 周(100%的 FSC 与 48%的 FMU,p < 0.001)也较差。与术前和术后的 FMU 相比,FSC 更有可能提供标准的成像建议,包括 T1 加权(T1W)、梯度回波(GE)或平面回波胎儿脑和脊柱成像,在一个或两个正交平面上(p < 0.001)。
对于 OSB 胎儿手术评估,及时获得了有监督的 MRI。然而,获得足够的正交平面的胎儿脑和脊柱图像的情况较少,这对于确定手术资格和确定胎儿手术后后脑疝的逆转非常重要。我们的证据表明,需要针对 OSB 的胎儿 MRI 提供具体的指导。我们提出了一个关于 MRI 采集和报告的示例指导。