King's College London, UK.
Brighton and Sussex Medical School, UK.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Jul;25(3):2377-2389. doi: 10.1177/15248380231211955. Epub 2023 Nov 22.
There is no consensus on the outcomes needed for the recovery and reintegration of survivors of modern slavery and human trafficking. We developed the Modern Slavery Core Outcome Set (MSCOS) to address this gap. We conducted three English-language reviews on the intervention outcomes sought or experienced by adult survivors: a qualitative systematic review (4 databases, 18 eligible papers, thematic analysis), a rapid review of quantitative intervention studies (four databases, eight eligible papers, content analysis) and a gray literature review (2 databases, 21 websites, a call for evidence, 13 eligible papers, content analysis). We further extracted outcomes from 36 pre-existing interview transcripts with survivors, and seven interviews with survivors from underrepresented groups. We narrowed down outcomes via a consensus process involving: a three-stage E-Delphi survey (191 respondents); and a final consensus workshop (46 participants). We generated 398 outcomes from our 3 reviews, and 843 outcomes from interviews. By removing conceptual and literal duplicates, we reduced this to a longlist of 72 outcomes spanning 10 different domains. The E-Delphi produced a 14-outcome shortlist for the consensus workshop, where 7 final outcomes were chosen. Final outcomes were: "long-term consistent support," "secure and suitable housing," "safety from any trafficker or other abuser," "access to medical treatment," "finding purpose in life and self-actualisation," "access to education," and "compassionate, trauma-informed services." The MSCOS provides outcomes that are accepted by a wide range of stakeholders and that should be measured in intervention evaluation.
目前,关于现代奴役和人口贩运幸存者的康复和重返社会所需的结果,尚未达成共识。我们制定了《现代奴役核心结果集(MSCOS)》,以解决这一差距。我们对成年幸存者寻求或经历的干预结果进行了三项英语审查:一项定性系统评价(4 个数据库,18 篇合格论文,主题分析)、一项快速定量干预研究综述(4 个数据库,8 篇合格论文,内容分析)和一项灰色文献综述(2 个数据库,21 个网站,征求证据,13 篇合格论文,内容分析)。我们进一步从 36 份与幸存者的现有访谈记录和 7 份来自代表性不足群体的幸存者访谈中提取结果。我们通过涉及:三阶段 E-Delphi 调查(191 名受访者)和最终共识研讨会(46 名参与者)的共识过程来缩小结果范围。我们从 3 项审查中生成了 398 项结果,从访谈中生成了 843 项结果。通过去除概念和文字重复,我们将其减少到一个由 10 个不同领域的 72 个结果组成的长列表。E-Delphi 为共识研讨会产生了一个 14 项结果的短名单,其中有 7 项最终结果入选。最终结果为:“长期持续支持”、“安全且合适的住房”、“免受任何人口贩子或其他施虐者的伤害”、“获得医疗”、“在生活中找到目标和自我实现”、“获得教育”和“富有同情心、以创伤为中心的服务”。MSCOS 提供了广泛的利益相关者接受的结果,这些结果应在干预评估中进行衡量。