Lo Rito Mauro, Brindicci Ylenia Claudia Maria, Moscatiello Mario, Varrica Alessandro, Reali Matteo, Saracino Antonio, Chessa Massimo, Aloisio Tommaso, Isgrò Giuseppe, Giamberti Alessandro
Department of Congenital Cardiac Surgery, IRCCS Policlinico San Donato, San Donato Milanese, 20097 Milan, Italy.
Department of Pediatric and Adult Congenital Cardiology, IRCCS Policlinico San Donato, San Donato Milanese, 20097 Milan, Italy.
J Cardiovasc Dev Dis. 2023 Nov 6;10(11):452. doi: 10.3390/jcdd10110452.
Minimally invasive surgeries for pediatric patients have been proposed for decades, with different approaches in mind. Minimal right axillary thoracotomy (MRAT), proposed two decades ago, allows the preservation of patients' safety alongside faster aesthetic and functional recovery. The MRAT did not become widely adopted due to the prejudice that to follow a minimally invasive approach, safety and efficacy must be compromised. With this study, we aim to compare MRAT to the standard median sternotomy approach with a focus on safety and clinical outcomes. Between January 2017 and April 2021, 216 patients diagnosed with ASD, pAVSD, or PAPVD underwent surgical repair with different approaches in the same period. MRAT was used for 78 patients, and median sternotomy was used for 138 patients. In this last group, standard median sternotomy (SMS) was used for 116 patients, while a minimal skin incision (SMS mini) was used for 22 patients. There were no major complications overall nor in each specific approach. MRAT enabled the successful repair of simple heart defects, providing similar post-operative and cardiological recovery. MRAT does not compromise patients' safety and does not prolong the duration of surgery once the learning curve is overcome, which is generally after 15-20 consecutive operations.
几十年来,人们一直提议对儿科患者进行微创手术,并有着不同的方法。二十年前提出的最小化右腋下开胸术(MRAT),在保障患者安全的同时,能让患者更快地实现美观和功能恢复。由于存在一种偏见,即认为采用微创方法就必须在安全性和有效性上做出妥协,MRAT并未得到广泛应用。通过这项研究,我们旨在比较MRAT与标准正中胸骨切开术,重点关注安全性和临床结果。在2017年1月至2021年4月期间,216例被诊断为房间隔缺损(ASD)、部分性房室通道缺损(pAVSD)或部分性肺静脉异位引流(PAPVD)的患者在同一时期接受了不同方法的手术修复。78例患者采用了MRAT,138例患者采用了正中胸骨切开术。在最后一组中,116例患者采用了标准正中胸骨切开术(SMS),22例患者采用了最小皮肤切口(SMS mini)。总体而言以及在每种具体方法中均未出现重大并发症。MRAT能够成功修复简单心脏缺陷,术后恢复和心脏功能恢复情况相似。MRAT不会损害患者安全,一旦克服学习曲线(通常是在连续进行15 - 20次手术后),也不会延长手术时间。