Director, AHRQ, Rockville, Maryland, USA.
AHRQ, Rockville, Maryland, USA
Tob Control. 2024 Nov 10;33(e2):e218-e224. doi: 10.1136/tc-2023-058136.
In 2023, President Biden issued an executive order requiring cost-benefit analyses for new regulations to account for distributional effects. To inform new tobacco regulations, we estimate for the first time racial and ethnic disparities in spending and outcomes associated with smoking.
With the 2008-2019 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey linked to the National Health Interview Survey, n=118 084 adults-years, logit models estimate the per cent of the top 10 health conditions attributable to smoking. Two-part regression models estimate the share of and total annual healthcare spending attributable to smoking.
White adults had higher ever-smoked rates, but minority smoking adults had twice as much of their annual medical spending associated with smoking than white smoking adults, 25% vs 12% (p<0.01). minority adults who smoked had 41% (p<0.05) higher risks of multiple chronic conditions associated with smoking than white adults. While the share of white smoking adults trying to quit declined to 53% in 2019, this desire increased to 63% for minorities. From 2008-2016, smoking comprised 7.5% of the nation's spending for white adults and 10.7% for minorities (p<0.05). In 2017-2019, this declined to 2.5% of the nation's spending for white adults and 8.9% for minorities (p<0.05). For any new antitobacco regulation, the cost savings would be $134 million per year for every 100 000 minorities averted from initiating smoking, 135% more than the $57 million saved annually for 100 000 white adults averted.
Minority adults may benefit substantially more from antitobacco regulations and past federal cost-benefit analyses would have overlooked this.
2023 年,拜登总统发布了一项行政命令,要求对新法规进行成本效益分析,以考虑分配效应。为了为新的烟草法规提供信息,我们首次估计了与吸烟相关的种族和族裔差异在支出和结果方面的情况。
利用 2008-2019 年医疗支出面板调查与全国健康访谈调查的数据进行链接,共有 118084 名成年人-年,对数模型估计吸烟导致的前 10 种健康状况的百分比。两部分回归模型估计与吸烟相关的医疗支出份额和总年度医疗支出。
白人成年人的吸烟率更高,但少数族裔吸烟成年人的吸烟相关年度医疗支出占比是白人吸烟成年人的两倍,分别为 25%和 12%(p<0.01)。与白人成年人相比,吸烟的少数族裔成年人与吸烟相关的多种慢性疾病的风险高 41%(p<0.05)。虽然 2019 年试图戒烟的白人吸烟成年人的比例下降到 53%,但这一愿望增加到了少数族裔的 63%。从 2008 年到 2016 年,吸烟占白人成年人全国支出的 7.5%,占少数族裔的 10.7%(p<0.05)。在 2017 年至 2019 年期间,这一比例下降到白人成年人全国支出的 2.5%和少数族裔的 8.9%(p<0.05)。对于任何新的反烟草法规,每避免 10 万少数族裔开始吸烟,每年可节省 1.34 亿美元,比避免 10 万白人成年人吸烟每年节省的 5700 万美元多 135%。
少数族裔成年人可能会从反烟草法规中获益更多,而过去的联邦成本效益分析可能忽略了这一点。