Okuhara Tsuyoshi, Shirabe Ritsuko, Kagawa Yumi, Okada Hiroko, Kiuchi Takahiro
Department of Health Communication, School of Public Health, Graduate School of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Department of Health Communication, Graduate School of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Heliyon. 2023 Nov 18;9(12):e22655. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e22655. eCollection 2023 Dec.
This study reviewed studies of the anticipated affect related with COVID-19 vaccination to understand gaps in currently available studies and practice implications.
We systematically searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, and other multiple databases for English language articles of studies that investigated COVID-19 vaccination related anticipated affects.
We identified seventeen studies. Thirteen studies focused anticipated regret from inaction (i.e., not vaccinated). Other studies focused anticipated regret from action (i.e., vaccinated), guilt from inaction, pride from action, and positive feelings from action. Eleven studies showed that anticipated regret from inaction was significantly associated with COVID-19 vaccination behavior or intention. Three of the 11 studies showed that anticipated regret from inaction was more strongly associated with vaccination behavior or intention than cognitive belief.
Most studies showed that positive associations between anticipated regret and COVID-19 vaccination outcomes. The use of messages that target cognitive beliefs as well as those that appeal to anticipated affect may be effective to promote COVID-19 vaccination. However, most studies employed a cross-sectional design and examined negative affect. Future studies should adopt an experimental design as well as examine positive affect.
本研究回顾了与新冠疫苗接种相关的预期情感的研究,以了解现有研究中的差距及实践意义。
我们系统检索了MEDLINE、CINAHL和其他多个数据库,查找调查新冠疫苗接种相关预期情感的英文研究文章。
我们识别出17项研究。13项研究聚焦于因不作为(即未接种疫苗)而产生的预期遗憾。其他研究聚焦于因作为(即接种疫苗)而产生的预期遗憾、因不作为而产生的内疚、因作为而产生的自豪以及因作为而产生的积极感受。11项研究表明,因不作为而产生的预期遗憾与新冠疫苗接种行为或意愿显著相关。11项研究中的3项表明,因不作为而产生的预期遗憾与接种行为或意愿的关联比认知信念更强。
大多数研究表明,预期遗憾与新冠疫苗接种结果之间存在正相关。使用针对认知信念以及那些诉诸预期情感的信息可能对促进新冠疫苗接种有效。然而,大多数研究采用横断面设计并考察了负面影响。未来的研究应采用实验设计并考察积极影响。