Goodyear Trevor, Oliffe John L, Kia Hannah, Jenkins Emily K, Knight Rod
University of British Columbia, Canada.
British Columbia Centre on Substance Use, Canada.
Health (London). 2025 Jan;29(1):118-139. doi: 10.1177/13634593231214942. Epub 2023 Dec 14.
There is growing awareness about issues of sexual consent, especially in autonomy-compromising or "non-ideal" contexts, including sex involving alcohol. Understanding the conditions needed for consensual sex to occur in this emergent milieu is critically important, especially for young men (ages 18-30 years) who normatively combine drinking alcohol with sex and are most often perpetrators of sexual violence. This study offers a discourse analysis of young men's alcohol use and sexual consent. Data are drawn from qualitative interviews with 76 young men (including gay, bisexual, queer, and straight men) in Vancouver, Canada, from 2018 to 2021. Informed by Kukla's non-ideal theory of sexual consent and critical and inclusive masculinities, this analysis identified three discursive frames: , and . In young men discussed their efforts to actively promote sexual and decisional autonomy for themselves and their sexual partners when drinking. Yet, in young men invoked discourses of disinhibition, deflection, and denial to normalize alcohol use as being somewhat excusatory for sexual violence, downplaying the role and responsibility of men. Lastly, men operationalized through a continuum of consent and of "meeting (masculine) expectations" when discussing sexual violence and victimization while intoxicated. Together, these discursive frames provide insights into the gendered nature of sexual violence and the extent to which idealized notions of sexual consent play out in the everyday lives of young men who use alcohol with sex. Findings hold philosophical and pragmatic implications for contemporary efforts to scaffold sexual consent.
人们越来越意识到性同意问题,尤其是在损害自主性或“非理想”的情境中,包括涉及酒精的性行为。了解在这种新出现的环境中发生双方自愿性行为所需的条件至关重要,特别是对于18至30岁的年轻男性而言,他们通常将饮酒与性行为结合在一起,而且往往是性暴力的实施者。本研究对年轻男性的饮酒行为和性同意进行了话语分析。数据来自2018年至2021年在加拿大温哥华对76名年轻男性(包括男同性恋者、双性恋者、酷儿和异性恋男性)进行的定性访谈。基于库克拉的非理想性同意理论以及批判性和包容性男性气质,该分析确定了三个话语框架: 、 和 。在 中,年轻男性讨论了他们在饮酒时为自己和性伴侣积极促进性自主和决策自主所做的努力。然而,在 中,年轻男性援引去抑制、转移和否认的话语,将饮酒行为正常化为对性暴力有一定的可原谅性,淡化了男性的角色和责任。最后,男性在讨论醉酒时的性暴力和受害情况时,通过一系列的同意和“满足(男性)期望”来实施 。这些话语框架共同揭示了性暴力的性别本质,以及理想化的性同意观念在将饮酒与性行为结合的年轻男性日常生活中的体现程度。研究结果对当代构建性同意的努力具有哲学和实际意义。