Massaro Daniele, Rezaeiravesh Saleh, Schlatter Philipp
SimEx/FLOW, Engineering Mechanics, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, 100 44, Sweden.
Department of Fluids and Environment/MACE, The University of Manchester, Manchester, M139PL, UK.
Sci Rep. 2023 Dec 15;13(1):22344. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-49747-1.
Information theory (IT) provides tools to estimate causality between events, in various scientific domains. Here, we explore the potential of IT-based causality estimation in turbulent (i.e. chaotic) dynamical systems and investigate the impact of various hyperparameters on the outcomes. The influence of Markovian orders, i.e. the time lags, on the computation of the transfer entropy (TE) has been mostly overlooked in the literature. We show that the history effect remarkably affects the TE estimation, especially for turbulent signals. In a turbulent channel flow, we compare the TE with standard measures such as auto- and cross-correlation, showing that the TE has a dominant direction, i.e. from the walls towards the core of the flow. In addition, we found that, in generic low-order vector auto-regressive models (VAR), the causality time scale is determined from the order of the VAR, rather than the integral time scale. Eventually, we propose a novel application of TE as a sensitivity measure for controlling computational errors in numerical simulations with adaptive mesh refinement. The introduced indicator is fully data-driven, no solution of adjoint equations is required, with an improved convergence to the accurate function of interest. In summary, we demonstrate the potential of TE for turbulence, where other measures may only provide partial information.
信息论(IT)为估计不同科学领域中事件之间的因果关系提供了工具。在此,我们探索基于信息论的因果关系估计在湍流(即混沌)动力系统中的潜力,并研究各种超参数对结果的影响。马尔可夫阶数,即时间滞后,对转移熵(TE)计算的影响在文献中大多被忽视。我们表明,历史效应显著影响TE估计,尤其是对于湍流信号。在湍流通道流中,我们将TE与自相关和互相关等标准度量进行比较,表明TE具有主导方向,即从壁面指向流动核心。此外,我们发现,在一般的低阶向量自回归模型(VAR)中,因果时间尺度由VAR的阶数决定,而不是由积分时间尺度决定。最终,我们提出了TE作为一种灵敏度度量的新应用,用于在自适应网格细化的数值模拟中控制计算误差。引入的指标完全由数据驱动,无需求解伴随方程,对感兴趣的精确函数具有改进的收敛性。总之,我们展示了TE在湍流方面的潜力,而其他度量可能只能提供部分信息。