Petrokubi R J, Jeffries G H
Gastroenterology. 1979 Oct;77(4 Pt 1):691-5.
The effectiveness of cimetidine vs. antacid in the treatment of patients with scleroderma and symptomatic reflux esophagitis was studied in a double-blind cross-over controlled trial. Fifteen patients were initially randomized to either cimetidine (300 mg four times daily) with placebo antacid, or placebo tablet (1 four times daily) with Mylanta II (30 ml four times daily and PRN). After 8 wk of therapy on the initial regimen, each patient was crossed over to the alternate regimen for an additional 8 wk of therapy. The severity of symptoms during each treatment period was estimated by patient interviews and changes in esophagitis were evaluated endoscopically. Cimetidine gave significantly greater relief of heartburn than antacid regardless of the initial randomization. Cimetidine also resulted in significant endoscopic improvement of the esophageal mucosa whereas antacid was without effect. Neither cimetidine nor antacid produced any improvement in esophageal stricture size or lower esophageal sphincter pressure. Cimetidine was without toxicity whereas antacid therapy frequently produced diarrhea.
在一项双盲交叉对照试验中,研究了西咪替丁与抗酸剂治疗硬皮病和有症状反流性食管炎患者的疗效。15名患者最初被随机分为接受西咪替丁(每日4次,每次300毫克)加安慰剂抗酸剂,或安慰剂片(每日4次,每次1片)加氢氧化铝镁(每日4次,每次30毫升,必要时服用)。在初始治疗方案治疗8周后,每位患者交叉接受替代方案再治疗8周。通过患者访谈评估每个治疗期间症状的严重程度,并通过内镜检查评估食管炎的变化。无论最初的随机分组如何,西咪替丁缓解烧心的效果都比抗酸剂显著更好。西咪替丁还使食管黏膜在内镜检查中有显著改善,而抗酸剂则无效果。西咪替丁和抗酸剂均未使食管狭窄大小或食管下括约肌压力有任何改善。西咪替丁无毒性,而抗酸剂治疗经常导致腹泻。