Bascom Palmer Eye Institute, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, Florida, USA.
Curr Opin Ophthalmol. 2024 May 1;35(3):244-251. doi: 10.1097/ICU.0000000000001028. Epub 2023 Dec 20.
To discuss relevant clinical outcomes, challenges, and future opportunities of gene therapy in Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON).
Results of G11778A LHON Phase 3 randomized clinical trials with unilateral intravitreal rAAV2/2-ND4 allotopic gene therapy show good safety and unexpected bilateral partial improvements of BCVA (best-corrected visual acuity) with mean logMAR BCVA improvements of up to near ∼0.3 logMAR (3 lines) in the treated eyes and ∼0.25 logMAR (2.5 lines) in the sham-treated or placebo-treated fellow eyes. Final mean BCVA levels after gene therapy were in the range of ∼1.3 logMAR (20/400) bilaterally.
Bilateral partial improvement with unilateral LHON gene therapy was unanticipated and may be due to treatment efficacy, natural history, learning effect, and other mediators. The overall efficacy is limited given the final BCVA levels. The sequential progressive visual loss and varied occurrence of spontaneous partial improvement in LHON confound trial results. Future clinical trials with randomization of patients to a group not receiving gene therapy in either eye would help to assess treatment effect. Promising future LHON gene therapy strategies include mitochondrially-targeted-sequence adeno-associated virus ('MTS-AAV') for direct delivery of the wild-type mitochondrial DNA into the mitochondria and CRISPR-free, RNA-free mitochondrial base editing systems. Signs of anatomical optic nerve damage and objective retinal ganglion cell dysfunction are evident in the asymptomatic eyes of LHON patients experiencing unilateral visual loss, indicating the therapeutic window is narrowing before onset of visual symptoms. Future treatment strategies utilizing mitochondrial base editing in LHON carriers without optic neuropathy holds the promise of a more advantageous approach to achieve optimal visual outcome by reducing disease penetrance and mitigating retinal ganglion cell loss when optic neuropathy develops.
探讨基因治疗莱伯遗传性视神经病变(LHON)的相关临床结局、挑战和未来机遇。
G11778A LHON 期 3 项单侧玻璃体内 rAAV2/2-ND4 异位基因治疗的随机临床试验结果显示,该疗法具有良好的安全性,且出人意料地使 BCVA(最佳矫正视力)出现双侧部分改善,治疗眼的平均 logMAR BCVA 提高了近 ∼0.3 logMAR(3 行),假手术或安慰剂治疗的对侧眼提高了 ∼0.25 logMAR(2.5 行)。基因治疗后的最终平均 BCVA 水平在双侧均为 ∼1.3 logMAR(20/400)。
单侧 LHON 基因治疗出现双侧部分改善是出乎意料的,可能与治疗效果、自然史、学习效应和其他介质有关。鉴于最终的 BCVA 水平,整体疗效有限。LHON 基因治疗的后续渐进性视力丧失和自发性部分改善的不同发生使临床试验结果复杂化。未来对患者进行随机分组,一组双侧眼均不接受基因治疗的临床试验将有助于评估治疗效果。有前途的未来 LHON 基因治疗策略包括靶向线粒体的序列腺相关病毒(“MTS-AAV”),用于将野生型线粒体 DNA 直接递送至线粒体,以及无 CRISPR、无 RNA 的线粒体碱基编辑系统。在单侧视力丧失的 LHON 患者无症状眼中,已出现视神经解剖损伤和客观视网膜节细胞功能障碍的迹象,表明在视觉症状出现之前,治疗窗正在变窄。未来在没有视神经病变的 LHON 携带者中利用线粒体碱基编辑的治疗策略有望通过降低疾病穿透性和减轻视神经病变时视网膜节细胞丢失,实现更有利的方法来获得最佳的视觉结果。