Institute of Occupational, Social and Environmental Medicine, Medical Faculty, RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany.
Social Accident Insurance Institution for the Energy, Textile, Electrical and Media Products Sectors (BG ETEM), Köln, Germany.
Inquiry. 2023 Jan-Dec;60:469580231220605. doi: 10.1177/00469580231220605.
Physical activity-related workplace interventions can be counterstrategies for physical inactivity due to office work. Newly introduced programs should be evaluated for success. This study aimed to evaluate the intervention of a workplace active rest program and to compare a prospective and retrospective design of evaluation. A Germany-wide multicenter evaluation of a 3-month workplace active rest program (30 min, once a week) was carried out at 14 locations with a longitudinal pre/post design by means of an anonymous questionnaire (n = 405, n = 369). The participants' program-related changes in targeted characteristics regarding posture, function, complaints and physical awareness were collected with a questionnaire in a prospective design and afterward retrospectively. The prospective evaluation showed a significant improvement in the target characteristic "postural muscles in the neck area". In the retrospective survey, all target characteristics improved significantly. There were no differences between locations. The workplace active rest program in this study had positive effects on the perception of postural neck muscle status regardless of prospective or retrospective approach. Selection of survey mode should depend on desired outcome and consecutive influencing factors. In this specific case, retrospective survey could give more indirect information about overall satisfaction with the program and job although being influenced by response bias. Recall bias should be relatively small for shorter time periods assessed. Future studies should account for corresponding bias and specifics of target characteristics regardless of the chosen approach to survey.
与身体活动相关的工作场所干预措施可以作为对抗因办公而导致的身体不活动的对策。新引入的计划应评估其成功与否。本研究旨在评估工作场所主动休息计划的干预效果,并比较前瞻性和回顾性评价设计。在德国 14 个地点进行了一项为期 3 个月的工作场所主动休息计划(30 分钟,每周一次)的全国多中心评估,采用纵向预/后设计,通过匿名问卷进行(n=405,n=369)。参与者在以问卷进行前瞻性设计的过程中收集了与目标特征(姿势、功能、投诉和身体意识)相关的计划相关变化,然后在回顾性调查中收集了与目标特征相关的计划相关变化。前瞻性评估显示,目标特征“颈部区域姿势肌肉”有显著改善。在回顾性调查中,所有目标特征均显著改善。地点之间没有差异。本研究中的工作场所主动休息计划对姿势颈部肌肉状况的感知有积极影响,无论采用前瞻性还是回顾性方法。调查模式的选择应取决于预期的结果和后续的影响因素。在这种特殊情况下,尽管受到回应偏差的影响,回顾性调查可以提供关于对计划和工作的整体满意度的更间接信息。对于评估时间较短的情况,回忆偏差应该相对较小。未来的研究应考虑到无论选择哪种调查方法,都应考虑到相应的偏差和目标特征的特殊性。