Warwick-Giles Lynsey, Hutchinson Joseph, Checkland Kath, Hammond Jonathan, Bramwell Donna, Bailey Simon, Sutton Matt
Centre for Primary Care and Health Services Research, University of Manchester, Manchester.
Centre for Health Services Studies, University of Kent, Canterbury.
Br J Gen Pract. 2024 Apr 25;74(742):e290-e299. doi: 10.3399/BJGP.2023.0258. Print 2024 May.
Significant health inequalities exist in England. Primary care networks (PCNs), comprised of GP practices, were introduced in England in 2019 with funding linked to membership. PCNs have been tasked with tackling health inequalities.
To consider how the design and introduction of PCNs might influence their ability to tackle health inequalities.
A sequential mixed-methods study of PCNs in England.
Linear regression of annual PCN-allocated funding per workload-weighted patient on income deprivation score from 2019-2023 was used. Qualitative interviews and observations of PCNs and PCN staff were undertaken across seven PCN sites in England (July 2020-March 2022).
Across 1243 networks in 2019-2020, a 10% higher level of income deprivation resulted in £0.31 (95% confidence interval [CI] = £0.25 to £0.37), 4.50%, less funding per weighted patient. In 2022-2023, the same difference in deprivation resulted in £0.16 (95% CI = £0.11 to £0.21), 0.60%, more funding. Qualitative interviews highlighted that, although there were requirements for PCNs to tackle health inequalities, the policy design, and PCN internal relationships and maturity, shaped and sometimes restricted how PCNs approached this task locally.
Allocated PCN funding has become more pro-poor over time, suggesting that the need to account for deprivation within funding models is understood by policymakers. The following additional approaches have been highlighted that could support PCNs to tackle inequalities: better management support; encouragement and support to redistribute funding internally to support practices serving more deprived populations; and greater specificity in service requirements.
英国存在显著的健康不平等现象。由全科医生诊所组成的初级医疗网络(PCNs)于2019年在英国引入,其资金与成员数量挂钩。PCNs的任务是解决健康不平等问题。
探讨PCNs的设计和引入方式如何影响其解决健康不平等问题的能力。
对英国PCNs进行的一项序贯混合方法研究。
采用2019 - 2023年按工作量加权患者分配的年度PCN资金对收入剥夺分数的线性回归分析。对英国七个PCN站点的PCNs及其工作人员进行了定性访谈和观察(2020年7月至2022年3月)。
在2019 - 2020年的1243个网络中,收入剥夺水平每提高10%,每位加权患者的资金就减少0.31英镑(95%置信区间[CI]=0.25英镑至0.37英镑),即减少4.50%。在2022 - 2023年,相同的剥夺差异导致资金增加0.16英镑(95% CI = 0.11英镑至0.21英镑),即增加0.60%。定性访谈强调,尽管要求PCNs解决健康不平等问题,但政策设计、PCN内部关系和成熟度塑造并有时限制了PCNs在当地处理这项任务的方式。
随着时间的推移,分配给PCN的资金变得更加有利于贫困人口,这表明政策制定者理解在资金模式中考虑剥夺因素的必要性。已强调以下额外方法可支持PCNs解决不平等问题:更好的管理支持;鼓励和支持在内部重新分配资金,以支持为更多贫困人群服务的诊所;以及在服务要求上更加明确具体。