Öztürk Akın, Karakaşlı Ahmet, Erbil Güven, Gökgöz Mehmet Burak, Yapici Furkan
Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Mengücek Gazi Hospital, Erzincan, TUR.
Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Dokuz Eylül University Faculty of Medicine, İzmir, TUR.
Cureus. 2024 Jan 9;16(1):e51941. doi: 10.7759/cureus.51941. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Background The human vertebral column generates movements under versatile, dynamic loads. Understanding how the spine reacts to these movements and loads is crucial for developing new spine implants and surgical treatments for intervertebral disc injuries. Mechanically uni-axial compression models have been extensively studied. However, the spine's daily loading is not limited to compression, so it is crucial to measure its behavior in all movements (flexion-extension, rotation, and axial compression). Methods This study utilized L1-L5 segments from 19 healthy adult sheep spines. The L2-L3 disc of the first spine underwent only histological evaluation without biomechanical testing to define basic histological parameters. The remaining 18 were divided into three groups of six and subjected to biomechanical tests. Different mechanisms for three groups of spinal segments were prepared, and tests were performed on Shimadzu AG-IS 10 KN (Universal Drawing Press, Kyoto, Japan). An axial load (800 N) was applied to the first group, an axial load with 15 degrees of flexion to the second group, and an axial load with 10 degrees of rotation plus 15 degrees of flexion to the third group. A biomechanical evaluation of the maximum elongation amounts (MEAs) was performed and compared between the groups. Then, the L2-L3 discs were removed from the sheep spines, and a histological examination of the discs was conducted using Hematoxylin-Eosin (HE), Alcian Blue (AB), and Masson's Trichrome (MT) staining. Results The mean MEA ± Standard Deviation (Range) was 1.39 ± 0.38 (0.91-1.94) for Group 1, 2.02 ± 0.75 (0.91-3.01) for Group 2, and 2.47 ± 1.09 (0.64-3.9) for Group 3. Biomechanically, although MEAs increased from Group 1 to Group 3 (meaning that the mean MEAs increased as the number of types of applied force increased), there was no statistically significant difference between the groups regarding the MEAs (P = 0.092). Histologically, no significant differences were observed between all groups after HE staining. In all groups, hypercellularity, edema in the connective tissue, separation between tissue layers, delamination, and signs of swelling and necrosis in the cells were observed similarly. For the AB staining, there was a decrease in the glycosaminoglycan (GAG) structure in the tissue samples compared to the control tissue, but no significant differences were observed between the groups. However, it was observed that the stratification in Group 3 was slightly more deteriorated than in the other groups. For the MT staining, collagen structure deterioration was observed in all groups. It was observed that the amount of collagen was significantly reduced compared to the control tissue. Conclusion As a result, when the axial load is applied biomechanically, there is more displacement of the vertebral discs in Group 3 with multidimensional movements. Furthermore, histological studies revealed deterioration between tissue layers when exposed to complex movements, and the degradation of stratification in group 3 compared to other loading combinations in groups 2 and 3 may indicate the role of complex loads in the formation of disc herniation.
背景 人类脊柱在多种动态负荷下产生运动。了解脊柱如何对这些运动和负荷做出反应对于开发用于椎间盘损伤的新型脊柱植入物和手术治疗方法至关重要。机械单轴压缩模型已得到广泛研究。然而,脊柱的日常负荷并不局限于压缩,因此测量其在所有运动(屈伸、旋转和轴向压缩)中的行为至关重要。方法 本研究使用了19个健康成年绵羊脊柱的L1-L5节段。第一个脊柱的L2-L3椎间盘仅进行组织学评估,不进行生物力学测试,以确定基本的组织学参数。其余18个分为三组,每组6个,进行生物力学测试。为三组脊柱节段准备了不同的机制,并在岛津AG-IS 10 KN(万能拉伸压力机,日本京都)上进行测试。对第一组施加轴向负荷(800 N),对第二组施加轴向负荷并伴有15度屈曲,对第三组施加轴向负荷并伴有10度旋转加15度屈曲。对最大伸长量(MEA)进行生物力学评估并在组间进行比较。然后,从绵羊脊柱中取出L2-L3椎间盘,使用苏木精-伊红(HE)、阿尔辛蓝(AB)和马森三色(MT)染色对椎间盘进行组织学检查。结果 第一组的平均MEA±标准差(范围)为1.39±0.38(0.91-1.94),第二组为2.02±0.75(0.91-3.01),第三组为2.47±1.09(0.64-3.9)。在生物力学方面,尽管MEA从第一组到第三组有所增加(意味着平均MEA随着施加力的类型数量增加而增加),但各组之间在MEA方面没有统计学上的显著差异(P = 0.092)。在组织学上,HE染色后所有组之间未观察到显著差异。在所有组中,均类似地观察到细胞增多、结缔组织水肿、组织层分离、分层以及细胞肿胀和坏死的迹象。对于AB染色,与对照组织相比,组织样本中的糖胺聚糖(GAG)结构减少,但各组之间未观察到显著差异。然而,观察到第三组的分层比其他组略有恶化。对于MT染色,所有组均观察到胶原结构恶化。与对照组织相比,观察到胶原量显著减少。结论 结果表明,在生物力学上施加轴向负荷时,第三组多维度运动时椎间盘的位移更大。此外,组织学研究表明,暴露于复杂运动时组织层之间会出现退化,与第二组和第三组的其他负荷组合相比,第三组分层的退化可能表明复杂负荷在椎间盘突出形成中的作用。