Morales-Chainé Silvia, Palafox Germán, Robles-García Rebeca, Arenas-Landgrave Paulina, López-Montoya Alejandra, Félix-Romero Violeta, Imaz-Gispert Mireya Atzala
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico.
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City, Mexico.
J Affect Disord. 2024 Apr 1;350:476-484. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2023.12.077. Epub 2024 Jan 9.
Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, concern about widespread waves of depression and suicide emerged worldwide. Clarity on the relationship between mental health symptoms and warning signs of current self-harm or suicide thoughts and behaviors (ShSTB) in Mexican adults could be useful for designing effective public health policies and preventive strategies during health emergencies.
The present study uses a path model to explore the relationship between depressive symptoms, anxiety, and related distress, dysfunction, and somatization with ShSTB warning signs in Mexican adults during the COVID-19 pandemic. The study also describes the relative risks of these mental health variables for men and women, and for those who were seeking psychological care versus those who were not.
The study was conducted with 18,449 Mexicans (M = 33 years, SD = 11.00, range = 18-59), including 12,188 women (66.10 %) and 2706 (14.67 %) who were seeking psychological care. A web-based application included two multidimensional screening scales to evaluate depression, anxiety and somatic symptoms and related distress/dysfunction, as well as past and current ShSTB. Based on the participants' sex, the entire sample was randomly divided into two sub-samples to compare and replicate the Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) results, getting evidence of the multidimensionality of the scales. With the two sub-samples, we also tested the nested models from a structural equation model (SEM) to suggest a relationship between mental health and self-harm/suicide variables.
Our findings suggest that 31 % of participants were at risk for depression, 42.30 % for anxiety, 38.30 % for Marked Distress, Dysfunction and Somatization (MDDS), 33.30 % for at least one ShSTB, and 4.20 % for Previous Self Harm Thoughts and Behaviors (PShTB) during the COVID-19 pandemic. A greater percentage of women and participants seeking psychological care showed high levels of mental health symptoms, PShTB, MDDS, and ShSTB. The path model suggested a direct influence of PShTB and MDDS on ShSTB. Depression symptoms lead to ShSTB in three possible ways: through PShTB, PShTB affecting MDDS, and generalized anxiety affecting MDDS.
The pandemic was accompanied by a high prevalence of depression-anxiety, marked distress, dysfunction and somatization and self-harm/suicide thoughts and behaviors. The findings of this study suggest evidence over the well-known association between depression and anxiety, and between depression, previous self-harm thoughts and behaviors, and self-harm/suicide. The evidence suggests to distinguish when participants were suffering from MDDS and anxious depression from those only suffering from depression. The methodological conditions of the study suggest a comprehensive model of ShSTB prevention. Findings also suggest the need to care for Mexicans with depressive symptoms and PShTB as well as those suffering from anxious depression with MDDS to prevent suicide, by implementing effective public health policies and preventive strategies to reduce the mental health gap during health emergencies.
This research was a cross-sectional study, suggesting that future analyses should focus on the evaluation of its consistency with confirmed diagnoses of mental health disorders, self-harm/suicide risks, and the effect of remote psychological help to address these problems.
在新冠疫情早期,全球范围内出现了对抑郁症和自杀潮的担忧。明确墨西哥成年人心理健康症状与当前自我伤害或自杀想法及行为(ShSTB)的警示信号之间的关系,可能有助于在卫生紧急情况期间设计有效的公共卫生政策和预防策略。
本研究使用路径模型来探索新冠疫情期间墨西哥成年人抑郁症状、焦虑以及相关痛苦、功能障碍和躯体化与ShSTB警示信号之间的关系。该研究还描述了这些心理健康变量在男性和女性、寻求心理护理者与未寻求心理护理者中的相对风险。
该研究对18449名墨西哥人(平均年龄33岁,标准差11.00,年龄范围18 - 59岁)进行,其中包括12188名女性(66.10%)和2706名(14.67%)寻求心理护理的人。一个基于网络的应用程序包含两个多维筛查量表,用于评估抑郁、焦虑和躯体症状以及相关痛苦/功能障碍,以及过去和当前的ShSTB。根据参与者的性别,将整个样本随机分为两个子样本,以比较和复制验证性因子分析(CFA)结果,从而获得量表多维性的证据。利用这两个子样本,我们还测试了结构方程模型(SEM)中的嵌套模型,以表明心理健康与自我伤害/自杀变量之间的关系。
我们的研究结果表明,在新冠疫情期间,31%的参与者有抑郁风险,42.30%有焦虑风险,38.30%有明显痛苦、功能障碍和躯体化(MDDS)风险,33.30%至少有一个ShSTB风险,4.20%有既往自我伤害想法和行为(PShTB)风险。更大比例的女性和寻求心理护理的参与者表现出高水平的心理健康症状、PShTB、MDDS和ShSTB。路径模型表明PShTB和MDDS对ShSTB有直接影响。抑郁症状通过三种可能的方式导致ShSTB:通过PShTB,PShTB影响MDDS,以及广泛性焦虑影响MDDS。
疫情伴随着抑郁症 - 焦虑症、明显痛苦、功能障碍和躯体化以及自我伤害/自杀想法和行为的高患病率。本研究结果表明了抑郁症与焦虑症之间,以及抑郁症、既往自我伤害想法和行为与自我伤害/自杀之间存在关联的证据。证据表明需要区分参与者是患有MDDS和焦虑性抑郁症,还是仅患有抑郁症。该研究的方法学条件提示了一个ShSTB预防的综合模型。研究结果还表明,需要通过实施有效的公共卫生政策和预防策略来照顾有抑郁症状和PShTB的墨西哥人,以及患有伴有MDDS的焦虑性抑郁症的人,以预防自杀,缩小卫生紧急情况期间的心理健康差距。
本研究是一项横断面研究,这表明未来的分析应侧重于评估其与心理健康障碍确诊、自我伤害/自杀风险以及远程心理帮助解决这些问题的效果的一致性。