Giangregorio Francesco, Mosconi Emilio, Debellis Maria Grazia, Palermo Eliana, Provini Stella, Mendozza Manuela, Ricevuti Laura, Esposito Ciro
Internal Medicine, Codogno Hospital, Codogno, Italy.
Ultrasound Int Open. 2024 Jan 5;10:a21961599. doi: 10.1055/a-2196-1599.
Handheld ultrasound (HH-US) answers simple clinical questions in emergencies. We performed conventional US with HH-US at the patient's bedside (BED) during a medical visit (MED) (BED MED-US). The purpose of this prospective study is to estimate BED MED-US reliability, its clinical impact in helping the clinician to formulate correct diagnoses, and its ability to save time and money. 1007 patients (519 M; age:76.42) were assessed (from March 2021 to November 2022) in one or more districts. Final diagnosis was determined with clinical and reference tests (chest RX/CT, abdominal CT, endoscopy, etc.). Sensitivity, specificity, LR+ and LR-, and corresponding AUROC were evaluated. HH-US diagnoses were classified as: confirmation (HH-US revealed the sonographic signs that confirmed the clinical diagnosis) (CO), exclusion (HH-US excluded the presence of the ultrasound signs of other pathologies, in the clinical differential diagnosis) (EX), etiological (HH-US reaches diagnosis in clinically doubtful cases) (ET), or clinically relevant incidental (HH-US diagnoses that change the patient's process completely) (INC). HH-US reliability: true-pos: 752; true-neg: 242; false-pos: 7; false-neg: 6 (sens: 99.1%, spec: 97.6%, LR+: 98.5; LR-: 00.15, AUROC: 0.997); clinical impact: CO-diagnosis: 21%; EX: 25%; ET: 47%; INC: 7%; saved time and money: approximately 35,572 minutes of work and 9324 euros. BED MED-US is a reliable clinical imaging system, with an important clinical impact both in diagnosis (etiological in 47%, incidental in 7%) and in the management of personnel resources.
手持超声(HH-US)可解答急诊中的简单临床问题。我们在医疗就诊(MED)期间于患者床边(BED)使用HH-US进行常规超声检查(BED MED-US)。这项前瞻性研究的目的是评估BED MED-US的可靠性、其在帮助临床医生做出正确诊断方面的临床影响以及其节省时间和金钱的能力。在2021年3月至2022年11月期间,对一个或多个地区的1007名患者(519名男性;年龄:76.42岁)进行了评估。通过临床和参考检查(胸部X线/CT、腹部CT、内镜检查等)确定最终诊断。评估了敏感性、特异性、阳性似然比(LR+)和阴性似然比(LR-)以及相应的受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUROC)。HH-US诊断分为:确诊(HH-US显示出证实临床诊断的超声征象)(CO)、排除(在临床鉴别诊断中,HH-US排除了其他病理超声征象的存在)(EX)、病因诊断(在临床可疑病例中,HH-US得出诊断)(ET)或临床相关偶发情况(HH-US诊断完全改变了患者的诊疗过程)(INC)。HH-US的可靠性:真阳性:752例;真阴性:242例;假阳性:7例;假阴性:6例(敏感性:99.1%,特异性:97.6%,LR+:98.5;LR-:0.15,AUROC:0.997);临床影响:确诊诊断:21%;排除:25%;病因诊断:47%;偶发情况:7%;节省的时间和金钱:约35572分钟的工作时间和9324欧元。BED MED-US是一种可靠的临床成像系统,在诊断(47%为病因诊断,7%为偶发情况)和人力资源管理方面均具有重要的临床影响。