Meherali Salima, Bhaumik Soumyadeep, Idrees Sobia, Kennedy Megan, Lassi Zohra S
Faculty of Nursing, College of Health Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Meta-research and Evidence Synthesis Unit, Health Systems Science, George Institute for Global Health, Sydney, Australia.
JMIR Res Protoc. 2024 Feb 13;13:e55081. doi: 10.2196/55081.
Digital or eHealth knowledge translation (KT) interventions have been identified as useful public health tools, particularly to advance sexual and reproductive health (SRH) among adolescents. Existing literature reviews on digital health interventions for adolescents' SRH demonstrate limitations, including shortcomings in reporting and comprehensiveness that limit the utility and trustworthiness of findings. However, there is a lack of evidence synthesis on the effectiveness of available digital or mobile health KT tools to promote SRH interventions for adolescents.
We aim to identify, map, and describe existing empirical evidence on the digital KT tools developed to improve adolescent SRH outcomes globally.
This study will be conducted using an evidence gap map (EGM) approach to address the objectives, including reviewing relevant literature and a landscape analysis of the outcomes of interest. The following electronic databases will be searched for retrieval of literature: MEDLINE (1946-present), Embase (1974-present), and Global Health (1910-present) via OVID; CINAHL (1936-present) via EBSCOhost; Scopus (1976-present); and Cochrane Library (1993-present) via Wiley. We will include only those studies that focused on adolescents aged 10-19 years and addressed SRH outcomes. We will include experimental studies (randomized or cluster randomized and nonrandomized controlled trials, including quasi-randomized, controlled before-after, and interruptive time series) and observational studies, that is, including prospective cohort and case-control studies. The experimental and observational studies will only be included in the presence of control or comparison arms. Studies with a historical control arm will be excluded. The systematic review software, Covidence (Ventas Health Innovation), will be used to screen and select the studies. Further, 2 independent reviewers will complete the first and second levels of screening of studies and any conflicts arising will be resolved by consensus between the 2 reviewers or by involving the third reviewer. We will conduct the quality assessment of all included studies using the Risk of Bias tool for randomized controlled trials and nonrandomized controlled trials, and AMSTAR2 for systematic reviews.
Papers screening, data extraction, and synthesis will be completed by March 2024. We will use EPPI-Mapper (The International Public Policy Observatory) software to generate an online evidence map and to produce the tables and figures for the descriptive report. This EGM review will identify areas with high-quality, evidence-based digital KT tools (for immediate scale and spread) and areas where few or no KT tools exist (for targeted KT tool development and research or policy prioritization).
This protocol focused on mapping eHealth KT tools that have been used in the literature to address SRH among adolescents. This will be the first EGM exercise to map digital KT tools to promote adolescents' SRH and will incorporate a range of published sources.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/55081.
数字或电子健康知识转化(KT)干预措施已被视为有用的公共卫生工具,特别是在促进青少年性与生殖健康(SRH)方面。现有的关于青少年SRH数字健康干预措施的文献综述存在局限性,包括报告和全面性方面的不足,这限制了研究结果的实用性和可信度。然而,缺乏关于现有数字或移动健康KT工具促进青少年SRH干预措施有效性的证据综合。
我们旨在识别、绘制并描述全球范围内为改善青少年SRH结果而开发的数字KT工具的现有实证证据。
本研究将采用证据缺口图(EGM)方法来实现这些目标,包括回顾相关文献以及对感兴趣的结果进行全景分析。将搜索以下电子数据库以检索文献:通过OVID检索MEDLINE(1946年至今)、Embase(1974年至今)和Global Health(1910年至今);通过EBSCOhost检索CINAHL(1936年至今);Scopus(1976年至今);以及通过Wiley检索Cochrane Library(1993年至今)。我们将仅纳入那些关注10至19岁青少年并涉及SRH结果的研究。我们将纳入实验研究(随机或整群随机以及非随机对照试验,包括准随机、前后对照和中断时间序列)和观察性研究,即包括前瞻性队列研究和病例对照研究。实验性和观察性研究仅在有对照或比较组的情况下才会被纳入。有历史对照臂的研究将被排除。将使用系统评价软件Covidence(Ventas Health Innovation)来筛选和选择研究。此外,2名独立评审员将完成研究的第一级和第二级筛选,出现的任何冲突将通过2名评审员之间的共识或由第三名评审员参与解决。我们将使用随机对照试验和非随机对照试验的偏倚风险工具以及系统评价的AMSTAR2对所有纳入研究进行质量评估。
论文筛选、数据提取和综合工作将于2024年3月完成。我们将使用EPPI-Mapper(国际公共政策观察站)软件生成在线证据图,并为描述性报告制作表格和图表。本次EGM综述将识别出拥有高质量、基于证据的数字KT工具的领域(以便立即推广和传播)以及几乎没有或不存在KT工具的领域(以便进行有针对性的KT工具开发和研究或政策优先排序)。
本方案专注于绘制文献中用于解决青少年SRH问题的电子健康KT工具。这将是首次绘制促进青少年SRH的数字KT工具的EGM实践,并将纳入一系列已发表的来源。
国际注册报告标识符(IRRID):DERR1-10.2196/55081。