Bouve College of Health Sciences, Northeastern University, Boston, MA, United States.
Bouve College of Health Sciences, Northeastern University, Boston, MA, United States.
Int J Drug Policy. 2024 Mar;125:104341. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2024.104341. Epub 2024 Feb 16.
As the overdose crisis unfolded, narratives mischaracterizing neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS) as "addicted babies" with echoes to the "crack babies" panic proliferated in mainstream media. his study examines NAS misinformation dynamics and characteristics over a seven-year period.
Based on a comprehensive query, Media Cloud was used to compile mainstream media content relating to NAS between 2015 and 2021. Articles were redundantly coded on key parameters such as speakers represented, publication source, and scientific accuracy.
Of the 348 articles meeting search criteria, 264 (76 %) featured misinformed narratives, 70 (20 %) featured informed narratives, and 14 (4 %) featured both informed and misinformed content. Most frequent misinformation elements related to misrepresentation of babies as "addicted" at birth and exaggeration of NAS symptomatology and long-term harms. Least represented voices were people most affected, with just 11 (2 %) featuring mothers who used opioids prepartum.
Since misinformation contributes to punitive legal responses and harms patient care, efforts to prevent, monitor, and address inaccurate and stigmatizing narratives are essential to improving policy and practice.
随着过量用药危机的爆发,将新生儿戒断综合征(NAS)错误描述为“上瘾的婴儿”的说法,以及类似于“可卡因婴儿”恐慌的说法在主流媒体中大量出现。本研究考察了七年来 NAS 错误信息的动态和特征。
基于全面查询,使用 Media Cloud 编译了 2015 年至 2021 年间与 NAS 相关的主流媒体内容。文章对代表人物、出版来源和科学准确性等关键参数进行了冗余编码。
在符合搜索条件的 348 篇文章中,264 篇(76%)包含了错误信息的叙述,70 篇(20%)包含了知情的叙述,14 篇(4%)包含了知情和错误信息的内容。最常见的错误信息元素与婴儿出生时即被错误描述为“上瘾”以及夸大 NAS 症状和长期危害有关。最缺乏代表性的声音是受影响最大的人,只有 11 人(2%)是产前使用阿片类药物的母亲。
由于错误信息导致惩罚性法律反应和损害患者护理,因此,努力预防、监测和解决不准确和污名化的叙述对于改善政策和实践至关重要。