Department of Surgery, New York University Grossman School of Medicine, New York, New York.
Division of Transplant Surgery, Department of Surgery, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands.
JAMA Intern Med. 2024 Apr 1;184(4):402-413. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2023.8184.
Identifying the mechanisms of structural racism, such as racial and ethnic segregation, is a crucial first step in addressing the persistent disparities in access to live donor kidney transplantation (LDKT).
To assess whether segregation at the candidate's residential neighborhood and transplant center neighborhood is associated with access to LDKT.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this cohort study spanning January 1995 to December 2021, participants included non-Hispanic Black or White adult candidates for first-time LDKT reported in the US national transplant registry. The median (IQR) follow-up time for each participant was 1.9 (0.6-3.0) years.
Segregation, measured using the Theil H method to calculate segregation tertiles in zip code tabulation areas based on the American Community Survey 5-year estimates, reflects the heterogeneity in neighborhood racial and ethnic composition. To quantify the likelihood of LDKT by neighborhood segregation, cause-specific hazard models were adjusted for individual-level and neighborhood-level factors and included an interaction between segregation tertiles and race.
Among 162 587 candidates for kidney transplant, the mean (SD) age was 51.6 (13.2) years, 65 141 (40.1%) were female, 80 023 (49.2%) were Black, and 82 564 (50.8%) were White. Among Black candidates, living in a high-segregation neighborhood was associated with 10% (adjusted hazard ratio [AHR], 0.90 [95% CI, 0.84-0.97]) lower access to LDKT relative to residence in low-segregation neighborhoods; no such association was observed among White candidates (P for interaction = .01). Both Black candidates (AHR, 0.94 [95% CI, 0.89-1.00]) and White candidates (AHR, 0.92 [95% CI, 0.88-0.97]) listed at transplant centers in high-segregation neighborhoods had lower access to LDKT relative to their counterparts listed at centers in low-segregation neighborhoods (P for interaction = .64). Within high-segregation transplant center neighborhoods, candidates listed at predominantly minority neighborhoods had 17% lower access to LDKT relative to candidates listed at predominantly White neighborhoods (AHR, 0.83 [95% CI, 0.75-0.92]). Black candidates residing in or listed at transplant centers in predominantly minority neighborhoods had significantly lower likelihood of LDKT relative to White candidates residing in or listed at transplant centers located in predominantly White neighborhoods (65% and 64%, respectively).
Segregated residential and transplant center neighborhoods likely serve as a mechanism of structural racism, contributing to persistent racial disparities in access to LDKT. To promote equitable access, studies should assess targeted interventions (eg, community outreach clinics) to improve support for potential candidates and donors and ultimately mitigate the effects of segregation.
识别结构性种族主义的机制,如种族和族裔隔离,是解决在活体供肾移植(LDKT)方面持续存在的获取机会不平等问题的关键第一步。
评估候选人居住社区和移植中心社区的隔离情况与 LDKT 机会之间是否存在关联。
设计、设置和参与者:本队列研究涵盖 1995 年 1 月至 2021 年 12 月期间,参与者包括在美国国家移植登记处报告的首次接受 LDKT 的非西班牙裔黑人和白人成年候选者。每位参与者的中位(IQR)随访时间为 1.9(0.6-3.0)年。
使用 Theil H 方法测量隔离程度,根据美国社区调查 5 年估计值,在邮政编码区域划分中计算隔离程度的三分位数,反映了社区种族和族裔构成的异质性。为了量化邻里隔离对 LDKT 的可能性,因果风险模型针对个体和邻里层面的因素进行了调整,并包括了隔离三分位数和种族之间的交互作用。
在 162587 名接受肾脏移植的候选者中,平均(SD)年龄为 51.6(13.2)岁,65141 名(40.1%)为女性,80023 名(49.2%)为黑人,82564 名(50.8%)为白人。在黑人候选者中,居住在高隔离社区与接受 LDKT 的机会降低 10%(调整后的危险比 [AHR],0.90[95%CI,0.84-0.97])相关,而在白人候选者中则无此关联(P 交互作用 = 0.01)。黑人候选者(AHR,0.94[95%CI,0.89-1.00])和白人候选者(AHR,0.92[95%CI,0.88-0.97])在高隔离的移植中心登记的候选者与在低隔离中心登记的候选者相比,接受 LDKT 的机会较低(P 交互作用 = 0.64)。在高隔离的移植中心社区内,在主要由少数族裔组成的社区登记的候选者接受 LDKT 的机会比在主要由白人组成的社区登记的候选者低 17%(AHR,0.83[95%CI,0.75-0.92])。与居住在或在主要由白人组成的社区登记的移植中心的白人候选者相比,居住在或在主要由少数族裔组成的社区登记的黑人候选者接受 LDKT 的可能性显著降低(分别为 65%和 64%)。
隔离的居住和移植中心社区可能是结构性种族主义的一种机制,导致在接受 LDKT 的机会方面持续存在种族差异。为了促进公平获取,研究应评估有针对性的干预措施(例如社区外展诊所),以改善对潜在候选者和供体的支持,并最终减轻隔离的影响。