Sánchez-Escudero Juan Pablo, Galvis-Herrera Ana María, Sánchez-Trujillo David, Torres-López Laura Cristina, Kennedy Cole J, Aguirre-Acevedo Daniel Camilo, Garcia-Barrera Mauricio A, Trujillo Natalia
National College of Public Health, University of Antioquia, Antioquia, Colombia.
Department of Psychology, University of Antioquia, Antioquia, Colombia.
Neuropsychol Rev. 2025 Mar;35(1):77-101. doi: 10.1007/s11065-024-09633-7. Epub 2024 Feb 26.
Over the past decade, research using virtual reality and serious game-based instruments for assessing spatial navigation and spatial memory in at-risk and AD populations has risen. We systematically reviewed the literature since 2012 to identify and evaluate the methodological quality and risk of bias in the analyses of the psychometric properties of VRSG-based instruments. The search was conducted primarily in July-December 2022 and updated in November 2023 in eight major databases. The quality of instrument development and study design were analyzed in all studies. Measurement properties were defined and analyzed according to COSMIN guidelines. A total of 1078 unique records were screened, and following selection criteria, thirty-seven studies were analyzed. From these studies, 30 instruments were identified. Construct and criterion validity were the most reported measurement properties, while structural validity and internal consistency evidence were the least reported. Nineteen studies were deemed very good in construct validity, whereas 11 studies reporting diagnostic accuracy were deemed very good in quality. Limitations regarding theoretical framework and research design requirements were found in most of the studies. VRSG-based instruments are valuable additions to the current diagnostic toolkit for AD. Further research is required to establish the psychometric performance and clinical utility of VRSG-based instruments, particularly the instrument development, content validity, and diagnostic accuracy for preclinical AD screening scenarios. This review provides a straightforward synthesis of the state of the art of VRSG-based instruments and suggests future directions for research.
在过去十年中,使用虚拟现实和基于严肃游戏的工具来评估高危人群和阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者空间导航和空间记忆的研究有所增加。我们系统回顾了自2012年以来的文献,以识别和评估基于虚拟现实严肃游戏(VRSG)的工具心理测量特性分析中的方法学质量和偏倚风险。检索主要在2022年7月至12月进行,并于2023年11月在八个主要数据库中更新。分析了所有研究中工具开发和研究设计的质量。根据COSMIN指南定义并分析测量特性。共筛选出1078条独特记录,按照选择标准,对37项研究进行了分析。从这些研究中,识别出30种工具。结构效度和效标效度是报告最多的测量特性,而结构效度和内部一致性证据报告最少。19项关于结构效度的研究被认为非常好,而11项报告诊断准确性的研究在质量上被认为非常好。大多数研究存在理论框架和研究设计要求方面的局限性。基于VRSG的工具是当前AD诊断工具包的宝贵补充。需要进一步研究以确定基于VRSG的工具的心理测量性能和临床效用,特别是工具开发、内容效度以及临床前AD筛查场景的诊断准确性。本综述对基于VRSG的工具的现状进行了直接综合,并提出了未来的研究方向。