Tong Xunliang, Zhang Xinyue, Wang Mengyuan, Wang Zijun, Dong Fawu, Gong Enying, Zuberbier Torsten, Li Yanming
Department of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Beijing Hospital, National Centre of Gerontology, Institute of Geriatric Medicine, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
Beijing Hospital, National Centre of Gerontology, Institute of Geriatric Medicine, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Clin Transl Allergy. 2024 Mar;14(3):e12344. doi: 10.1002/clt2.12344.
The impact of non-pharmacological interventions (NPIs) on asthma prevention and management is insufficiently examined. We aim to comprehensively evaluate and synthesize existing evidence regarding the effectiveness of various NPIs throughout the life course.
We conducted a systematic search and screening of reviews that examined the effectiveness of various NPIs on asthma prevention and control in the Cochrane Library, PubMed, Embase, and Ovid databases. Data extraction was performed by considering the type of NPIs and the life course stages of the target population. Recommendations were provided by considering the quality of review assessed using the AMSTAR2 tool and the consistency of findings across reviews.
We identified 145 reviews and mapped the evidence on the impact of 25 subtypes of NPIs on asthma prevention and control based on five stages of life course. Reviews indicated a shift of focus and various impacts of major NPIs on asthma prevention and control across life courses, while a few types of NPIs, such as physical exercise, appeared to be beneficial in children, adolescents and adults. Consistent and high-level evidence was observed only for psychological intervention on asthma control and quality of life among adults and older adults. Potential benefit with high-level evidence was reported on certain NPIs, such as vitamin D in reducing risk of developing asthma in offsprings in the prenatal stage, digital health interventions in improving asthma control from childhood to older adulthood, and breathing exercise in improving quality of life, asthma-related symptoms and lung function in adulthood and older adulthood.
This study emphasizes the significance of delivering NPIs to improve asthma prevention and management and highlights the heterogeneity regarding the impact of NPIs across life courses. High-quality research is urgently needed to further strengthen the evidence base of NPIs and tailored interventions should be considered in guideline development.
非药物干预(NPIs)对哮喘预防和管理的影响尚未得到充分研究。我们旨在全面评估和综合现有证据,以了解各种NPIs在整个生命过程中的有效性。
我们在Cochrane图书馆、PubMed、Embase和Ovid数据库中对审查进行了系统检索和筛选,这些审查研究了各种NPIs对哮喘预防和控制的有效性。通过考虑NPIs的类型和目标人群的生命阶段来进行数据提取。根据使用AMSTAR2工具评估的审查质量和各审查结果的一致性提供建议。
我们识别出145篇综述,并根据生命过程的五个阶段绘制了关于25种NPIs亚型对哮喘预防和控制影响的证据图。综述表明,主要NPIs在整个生命过程中对哮喘预防和控制的重点有所转移且影响各异,而一些类型的NPIs,如体育锻炼,似乎对儿童、青少年和成年人有益。仅在成人和老年人中,心理干预对哮喘控制和生活质量的影响有一致且高水平的证据。某些NPIs有高水平证据表明具有潜在益处,如产前阶段维生素D可降低后代患哮喘的风险,数字健康干预可改善从儿童期到老年期的哮喘控制,呼吸锻炼可改善成年和老年期的生活质量、哮喘相关症状和肺功能。
本研究强调了实施NPIs以改善哮喘预防和管理的重要性,并突出了NPIs在整个生命过程中影响的异质性。迫切需要高质量的研究来进一步加强NPIs的证据基础,并且在制定指南时应考虑量身定制的干预措施。