Zeng Steven L, Zhang Gloria X, Porras Denisse F, Curtis Caitrin M, Glener Adam D, Hernandez J Andres, Tian William M, Emovon Emmanuel O, Phillips Brett T
Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, North Carolina.
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Wake Forest University, Winston Salem, North Carolina.
Arch Plast Surg. 2024 Feb 7;51(1):139-146. doi: 10.1055/a-2202-9219. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Applying into plastic surgery (PS) is competitive. Lacking a home residency program (HRP) is another barrier. Our goal is to characterize challenges faced by PS applicants without HRPs and identify solutions. Surveys were designed for current integrated PS residents and applicants in the 2022 Match without HRPs. Surveys were distributed electronically. Only U.S. allopathic graduate responses were included. Of 182 individuals surveyed, 74 responded (39%, 33 residents, 41 applicants). Sixty-six percent reported feeling disadvantaged due to lack of an HRP. Seventy-six percent of applicants successfully matched. Of these, 48% felt they required academic time off (research year) versus 10% of unmatched applicants. Ninety-seven percent of matched applicants identified a mentor versus 40% of unmatched applicants ( < 0.05). Matched applicants identified mentors through research (29%) and cold calling/emailing (25%). Matched versus unmatched applicants utilized the following resources: senior students (74 vs. 10%, < 0.05) and social media (52 vs. 10%, < 0.05). Among residents, 16 had PS divisions (48%). Thirty-six percent with divisions felt they had opportunities to explore PS, compared with 12% without divisions. Residents without divisions felt disadvantaged in finding research (94 vs. 65%, < 0.05), delayed in deciding on PS (50 vs. 28%), and obtaining mentors (44 vs. 35%) and letters of recommendation (31 vs. 24%). PS residents and applicants without HRPs reported feeling disadvantaged when matching. The data suggest that access to departments or divisions assists in matching. We identified that external outreach and research were successful strategies to obtain mentorship. To increase awareness for unaffiliated applicants, we should increase networking opportunities during local, regional, and national meetings.
申请整形外科竞争激烈。缺乏本校住院医师培训项目是另一大障碍。我们的目标是描述没有本校住院医师培训项目的整形外科申请者所面临的挑战,并找出解决方案。
针对2022年住院医师招录中没有本校住院医师培训项目的整形外科住院医师和申请者设计了调查问卷。问卷通过电子方式分发。仅纳入美国opathic医学院毕业生的回复。
在182名接受调查的个体中,74人回复(39%,33名住院医师,41名申请者)。66%的人报告称因缺乏本校住院医师培训项目而感到处于劣势。76%的申请者成功匹配。其中,48%的人觉得他们需要学术休假(研究年),而未匹配的申请者中这一比例为10%。97%的匹配申请者找到了导师,而未匹配申请者中这一比例为40%(P<0.05)。匹配的申请者通过研究(29%)和主动联系/发邮件(25%)找到了导师。匹配与未匹配的申请者利用了以下资源:高年级学生(74%对10%,P<0.05)和社交媒体(52%对10%,P<0.05)。在住院医师中,16人所在科室有整形外科(48%)。有科室的人中有36%觉得他们有机会探索整形外科,而没有科室的人中这一比例为12%。没有科室的住院医师在寻找研究机会(94%对65%,P<0.05)、决定选择整形外科的时间延迟(50%对28%)、获得导师(44%对35%)和推荐信(31%对24%)方面感到处于劣势。
没有本校住院医师培训项目的整形外科住院医师和申请者在匹配时报告称感到处于劣势。数据表明,进入科室有助于匹配。我们发现外部拓展和研究是获得导师指导的成功策略。为了提高非附属申请者的知名度,我们应该在地方、区域和全国会议期间增加社交机会。