Gulati Kamal, Davies Julie, Gonzalez de la Fuente Angel, Singh Angel Rajan
Centralized Core Research Facility, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India
Global Business School for Health, University College London, London, UK.
BMJ Lead. 2024 Dec 23;8(4):318-323. doi: 10.1136/leader-2023-000970.
There is a notable gap in studies examining the impact of gender within sociocultural norms in non-western professional settings, especially concerning the well-being of women physicians.
Using purposive sampling and thematic data analysis, we recorded interviews with 30 physicians in India during May-July 2023. Participants were aged 34 to 65 years, with experience ranging from five to 35 years, in various clinical (37%), surgical (30%), paraclinical (23%) and hospital administration (10%) roles, 97% were postgraduates and 53% were women. The research questions explored how leadership roles happened, managing key challenges, barriers and enablers, and practical interventions to support women into medical leadership positions.
Findings revealed that the majority of interviewees believed gender-related barriers were obstructing women's progress and success in medical leadership roles in India. These barriers were identified within three overarching domains: (1) specialty, (2) organisational and (3) sociocultural. Interviewees commonly acknowledged the male-dominated landscape of medical leadership although some women stated that they did not perceive any barriers for women's advancement into leadership roles. Interestingly, some men surgeons held the perception that women might not be as effective in certain surgical disciplines, such as orthopaedics and neurosurgery. Some men physicians, however, considered women physicians in India to be highly effective multitaskers.
We recommend structural reforms in medical education, leadership development, workplace systems and cultures, and improved implementation of equality, diversity and inclusion policies in the Indian context.
在研究非西方职业环境中社会文化规范内性别影响方面,存在显著差距,尤其是关于女性医生的福祉。
采用目的抽样和主题数据分析,我们于2023年5月至7月对印度的30名医生进行了访谈记录。参与者年龄在34至65岁之间,经验从5年到35年不等,担任各种临床(37%)、外科(30%)、辅助临床(23%)和医院管理(10%)角色,97%为研究生,53%为女性。研究问题探讨了领导角色是如何产生的、应对关键挑战、障碍和推动因素,以及支持女性担任医学领导职位的实际干预措施。
研究结果显示,大多数受访者认为与性别相关的障碍阻碍了印度女性在医学领导角色中的进步和成功。这些障碍在三个总体领域中被识别出来:(1)专业领域,(2)组织层面,(3)社会文化层面。受访者普遍承认医学领导领域以男性为主导,尽管一些女性表示她们没有察觉到女性晋升到领导角色存在任何障碍。有趣的是,一些男性外科医生认为女性在某些外科领域,如骨科和神经外科,可能没有那么高效。然而,一些男性医生认为印度的女性医生是非常高效的多面手。
我们建议在医学教育、领导力发展、工作场所系统和文化方面进行结构性改革,并在印度背景下更好地实施平等、多样性和包容性政策。